Based on record review and interview, the facility failed to complete an appropriate medical screening exam (MSE) for 1 of 6 (#1) patients (pts.) who presented to the Emergency Department (ED) with suicidal ideations resulting in that patient's death by suicide after discharge from the ED, failed to document the actual time of the MSE for 3 of 20 pts (#2, 3, and 4), and failed to continuously monitor 4 of 6 ( #1, 3, 5 and 6) pt with suicidal ideations.
Based on record review and interview, the facility failed to complete an appropriate medical screening exam (MSE) for 1 of 6 (#1) patients (pts.) who presented to the Emergency Department (ED) with suicidal ideations resulting in that patient's death by suicide after discharge from the ED, failed to document the actual time of the MSE for 3 of 20 pts (#2, 3, and 4), and failed to continuously monitor 4 of 6 ( #1, 3, 5 and 6) pt with suicidal ideations. On 8/18/16 at 12:35 pm these findings resulted in an Immediate Jeopardy. A total of 20 patients were included in the sample. The Immediate Jeopardy was cited at 42 CFR 489.23(a).
Findings include:
Review of Policy and Procedure titled, "EMTALA Screening, Treatment, & Transfer of Patients" last reviewed 5/25/2016 states the following:
"The triage nurse will triage and prioritize patients. (Triage alone does not constitute a medical screening exam). Based on their acuity and room availability, patients will be directed either to an examination room or to the ED triage room and then placed in a room as it becomes available... Regardless of the order of patients established by triage, all patients must be given an appropriate medical screening examination to determine if an emergency medical condition exists and treated to stabilize the condition or transferred, in accordance with this policy."
Review of Policy and Procedure titled, "Suicidal Patients; MHTC Emergency Department" last reviewed 1/15/13 states as follows:
-If Patient is felt to have imminent potential risk for suicide the patient should be placed in a room that can be directly observed by staff or Security at all times. Security will be notified and should report to the ED. If security is unavailable, direct observation of patient will be performed by staff.
-Documentation of patient observations will be performed every 15 minutes.
-This documentation will be sent to Medical Records for scanning and will become a part of the patient's medical record.
-Psychiatric Services should be consulted and assist with evaluation and disposition of the patient.
#1
Review of Patient (Pt) 1's medical record (MR) revealed Pt 1 arrived in the ED on 5/23/16 at 11:31 AM with chief complaint documented as "(Pt 1's) desire to end his life".
Per review of Pt 1's nursing notes and assessments, Suicide Risk Assessment completed on 5/23/16 at 11:49 AM and revealed a "Yes" answer to the question "Does the patient have a history of suicide attempt or ideation". "Actions taken to address Suicide Risk" is listed as "None beyond standard unit procedures; Clothing removed; Request Psychiatrist consult".
Further review of Pt 1's ED Provider Notes including History and Physical dated 5/23/16 at 11:52 am revealed, "Patient reports that (Pt 1) has a previous suicide attempt by overdosing on his medications. However patient reports today (Pt 1) is not overdosed on any medications or pills or drugs." ED provider notes further revealed, "Patient does not have a definitive plan in place at this time however he reports overdosing on a bunch of pills is a possible option...Patient reports that (Pt 1) would like to be admitted to the hospital before (Pt 1) does something that (Pt 1) regrets."
Review of Pt 1's ED Physicians Psychiatric assessment documented on 5/23/16 at 11:52 am revealed that Pt 1 "Exhibits a depressed mood", "Expresses suicidal ideations", and "Expresses suicidal plans". Per "ED Course" documentation at 11:52 am, "Patient will be placed under suicide precautions here in the emergency department.", "Patient is medically cleared for behavioral health evaluation."
Further review of Pt 1's ED course documented at 11:52 AM reveals at 11:40 AM Pt 1 walked out of the exam room in underwear, removed underwear, then proceeded to attempt to walk out of the ED naked. Pt 1 was intercepted by a couple of nurses and brought back to the exam rooom and covered up.
Review of Pt 1's MR revealed a Suicide risk assessment documented on 5/23/16 at 11:49 AM and a Safety/coping assessment documented at 11:56 AM. Further review of the same record revealed there was no documentation of Pt 1 being continuously monitored and observed while on suicide precautions between 11:52 AM and 1:50 PM (as per policy, "Suicidal Patients; MHTC Emergency Department").
Per Social Worker "D's" progress notes documented on 5/23/16 at 2:36 PM, "D" revealed the following, "SW (social worker) approached (Pt 1 ' s) room and observed the pt leaving (Pt 1 ' s) room unclothed holding a blanket. Pt was observed having trouble keeping (Pt 1 ' s) eyes open....(Pt 1) kept eyes shut and was mumbling incoherent statements that were inaudible." Per "D ' s" documentation, Pt 1 would not respond to "D's" questions. "D" then told staff to call Crisis and have them assess Pt 1 for involuntary treatment. "D" then left the ED to consult with the psychiatrist on call, when "D" came back to ED to follow up with Pt 1 ' s assessments, "D" observed Pt 1 had been discharged .
Interview with ED Physician "G" on 7/19/2016 beginning at 2:20 PM, revealed "G" stated when developing a plan of care for patients who present with suicidal ideations, "G" relies heavily on the evaluation and suggestions from the behavioral health team including the social worker and Psychiatry consult to determine best course of action. When asked had "G" spoken to the social worker, the Crisis team, or Pt 1 ' s case manager in regards to Pt 1 "G" responded "No". "G" felt that Pt 1 ' s case manager could better assist Pt 1 in the outpatient setting. "G" felt Pt 1 was stable enough to be discharged to follow-up with Pt 1's case manager immediately following discharge from ED.
Per interview with Social Worker "D" on 7/20/16 beginning at 12:35 PM, "D" revealed Registered Nurse "F" (assigned to Pt 1) and ED Physician "G" did not contact "D" to discuss discharge plan prior to discharging Pt 1 home. "D" stated normally when patients present to ED with suicidal ideation and are uncooperative and not answering questions, the interdisciplinary team normally gets Crisis team and Police Department involved to assess a patient for potential involuntary admission. The Crisis team consists of trained mental health professionals from the County Human Services Department who assess patients and work in conjunction with the police department to determine if patient's qualify for police holds and involuntary admissions.
Per interview with Director of ED "B" on 7/20/16 at 1:05 PM, "B" revealed the Crisis team did not come to ED to assess Pt 1 prior to being discharged home.
Review of Patient 1's ED record revealed Patient 1's MR lacked documentation that Pt 1 received a comprehensive MSE that included a psychiatric assessment by a Mental Health Professional to determine if Patient 1 was experiencing a Psychiatric Emergency Medical Condition.
Per mandatory death report #2805 submitted by Rock County Human Services Department to the Wisconsin Department of Quality Assurance/Behavioral Health Certification Section, Pt 1 commited suicide at approximately 10:30 PM on 5/23/16 by jumping off a bridge.
#2
Review of Patient 2's 6/27/16 "ED Events" log revealed the following timeline:
-4:12 PM: Arrived in ED, triage started, patient roomed in ED, assigned nurse
-4:17 PM: Triage completed
-4:25 PM: Labs ordered
-4:26 PM: Assigned Physician
-4:38 PM: Labs ordered
-5:52 PM: Patient discharged (Home, against medical advice)
Review of Patient 2's MR revealed no documentation of the actual time of Patient 2's MSE to determine if Patient 2 is experiencing an emergency medical condition. Patient 2's ED Event Log did not list the "First Provider Evaluation" time to indicate the actual time of the MSE.
#3
Review of Patient 3's 5/7/16 "ED Events" log shows the following timeline:
-5:26 PM: Patient arrived in ED
-5:29 PM: Assign physician
-5:29 PM: Provider first Contact
-5:32 PM: Triage Started, patient roomed
-5:34 PM: Assign nurse
-5:46 PM: labs ordered
-7:13 PM: Remove attending
-7:13 PM: Assign attending, Provider First Contact
-9:08 PM: Patient discharged (to Psychiatric Hospital)
Review of Patient 3's ED record revealed no documentation of the actual time of Patient 3's MSE to determine if Patient 3 is experiencing an Emergency Medical Condition. Patient 3's ED Event Log did not list the "First Provider Evaluation" time to indicate when the MSE was performed.
Per Pt 3's ED record, Pt 3 was placed on suicide precautions due to expressing suicidal thoughts and plan. Per Pt 3's ED nursing notes, Suicide Risk assessment was documented at 5:37 PM and Safety/coping assessment documented at 5:45 PM. Between 5:45 PM and time of discharge at 9:08 PM there was no documentation of Pt 3 being continuously monitored and observed while on suicide precautions (as per policy, "Suicidal Patients; MHTC Emergency Department").
#4
Review of Patient 4's 5/14/16 "ED Events" log shows the following timeline:
-5:39 PM: Patient arrived in ED
-5:40 PM: Patient roomed, triage started
-5:41 PM: Labs ordered
-5:43 PM: Assign physician; Provider First Patient Contact
-8:11 PM: Remove Attending
-8:17 PM: Assign Physician; Provider First Patient Contact
-10:55 PM: Patient discharged (Psychiatric Hospital)
Review of Patient 4's MR revealed no documentation of the actual time of Patient 4's MSE to determine if Patient 4 was experiencing an Emergency Medical Condition. Patient 4's ED Event Log did not list the "First Provider Evaluation" time to indicate the actual time of the MSE.
#5
Per Pt 5's MR, Pt 5 arrived in the ED on 1/31/16 at 12:52 AM with complaint of suicide attempt and was placed on suicide precautions. Per Pt 5's MR, Suicide Risk assessment documented on 1/31/16 at 1:00 AM and Safety/Coping assessment documented on 1/31/16 at 1:13 AM. Further review of Pt #5 s MR revealed there was no documentation Pt 5 was being continuously monitored and observed while on suicide precautions between 1:13 AM and time of discharge 3:12 AM on 1/31/16 (as per policy, "Suicidal Patients; MHTC Emergency Department").
#6
Per review of Pt 6's MR, Pt 6 arrived in ED on 5/22/16 at 5:16 PM with complaints of suicidal ideation's. Social Worker progress notes documented on 5/22/16 at 7:04 PM revealed, "(Pt 6) brought in by PD (police department) after walking into police station stating (Pt 6) was suicidal. Pt still having suicidal thoughts with plan to jump of a bridge..."
Review of Pt 6's ED "Flowsheet" dated 5/22/16 revealed no documentation of nursing staff performing a Suicide Risk Assessment. Further review of Pt #6s MR reveals there was no documentation of Pt 6 being continuously monitored and observed while on suicide precautions between 5:45 PM and time of discharge at 8:29 PM on 5/22/16 (as per policy, "Suicidal Patients; MHTC Emergency Department").
Per interview with Registered Nurse "E" on 7/19/2016 beginning at 1:05 PM, "E" revealed Security observes patients on suicide precautions, if security is unavailable then the Registered Nurse or ED Technician should be continuously monitoring and observing patients and document these observations at least every 15 minutes in the patients MR.
Per interview with Director of ED "C" on 7/19/2016 beginning at 1:05 PM, "C" revealed Security should document these observations on the "Patient Observation Monitoring Flowsheet" as per policy, and these flowsheet should be scanned into the patients MR.
Per interview with ED Director "C" on 7/20/16 beginning at 9:45 am, "C" revealed the date and time on the ED Provider Note (History and Physical) indicates the time the assessment was documented, not necessarily the actual time of the assessment. "C" stated the MSE is represented by "First Provider Evaluation" time documented on the ED Event log. "C" stated physicians should be documenting time of "First Provider Evaluation" which indicates the actual time of the MSE. "C" stated "First Provider Contact" time on the ED Event log, does not indicate that a MSE has been done.
Per interview with Director of Quality "H" on 7/20/2016 beginning at 1:05 PM, "H" revealed during Department of Emergency Medicine Meeting on 4/27/2016, medical staff discussed requiring ED physicians to document First Provider Evaluations (MSE) in real time. Per "H" this new process was effective as of May 2016 and physicians were informed of new process via email. "H" stated the plan to monitor for compliance was to review random samples of 120 ED records quarterly; approximately 40 ED records monthly. As of 7/20/2016 "H" was unable to provide an acceptable plan addressing compliance with new documentation process including evidence of MR audits being performed.