Part I, Line 3c:
|
Financial assistance approval can apply to an assortment of patients such as those who have exhausted their Medicaid/TennCare benefits, those who qualified for Medicaid/TennCare after the date of service, deceased patients with no estate or assets, uninsured patients, and underinsured patients. While Ballad Health's qualifications for financial assistance is based on federal poverty guidelines, asset values may also be used to determine financial assistance eligibility. Unique circumstances may be assessed on a case-by-case basis. Charity approval covers current or active patient balances when they are approved and there is no limitation or cap on the amount of charity that a patient may receive. Ballad Health hospitals do not stop approving financial assistance for patient accounts if a hospital's charity write-offs exceed the hospital's charity budget.All Ballad Health hospitals provide an uninsured discount. The current uninsured discount for Critical Access Hospitals (CAH's) is 77% and for all other hospitals or physician practices it is 85%. In addition to the uninsured discount, many patients will further qualify for additional financial assistance. All patients seeking financial assistance must submit an application for financial assistance and submit documents in support of the information on the application, unless specifically excluded according to policy guidelines. Medicaid eligible patients will qualify for 100% financial assistance and not be required to complete the required documentation when: a) Medicaid eligibility requirements are met after the service is provided, b) non-covered charges occur on a Medicaid eligible encounter, or c) benefits have been exhausted. Deceased patients with no estate also qualify for 100% financial assistance.Financial assistance determinations may be retroactive for all outstanding balances. In addition, Ballad Health offers a number of programs with special discounts such as lactation consultation services, oncology treatment regimens, enrollment in various community programs and prescription drugs filled post-discharge.
|
Part I, Line 7:
|
The cost to charge ratio (worksheet 2 "ratio of patient care cost to charges") was used to calculate line 7a financial assistance (charity care) cost. MSHA's cost accounting system was used to determine losses from Tenncare and Medicaid reported on line 7b, with the exception of home health and a small physician clinic. A cost to charge ratio was used for their data because these are smaller divisions not available in MSHA's cost accounting software. Line 7e community health improvement includes costs that are taken directly from departmental operating reports or expenses specific to a community health event, with no additional overhead included in the cost. Line 7f health professions education is comprised of internships (primarily internal medicine residents, nursing, pharmacy, and therapy students) with schools and universities, allowing their health profession students to receive hands-on training in a hospital setting. MSHA's Medicare-approved programs include medical residents, pharmacy and pastoral care. For these programs, Medicare-approved costs and Medicare reimbursement comes from filed Medicare cost reports. The Ballad Health Organizational Development Department (OD) maintains records for the non-Medicare programs. Only labor costs are included for MSHA team members that provide training (no overhead is applied) and only a percentage of team members' time is attributed to actual training. For line 7g subsidized health care services, MSHA's cost accounting system is used because MSHA has established, standard costing reports for these services. There are exceptions where MSHA does not use the cost accounting system. A small clinic inside JCCH, a federally designated critical access hospital, is subsidized by JCCH and the clinic's departmental operating report is used to compute the clinic's community benefit. The second exception is a palliative care program. For this program, the department's operating report is used. MSHA is careful to ensure no double counting of cost. Although there are other service lines within MSHA hospitals that lose money, MSHA does not report services that hospitals are required by state licensure to provide, routine services or ancillary services. Line 7h research represents MSHA's expense allocation from Ballad Health for research. Line 7i cash and in-kind contributions includes cash disbursements and in-kind donations of medications to local nonprofit rescue squads and fire departments. In-kind donations of medications are based on actual cost for these items.
|
Part II, Community Building Activities:
|
MSHA leaders support and encourage all team members to volunteer time, money and skills to community service projects and charitable organizations. Senior leaders and board members set a positive example for MSHA team members, serving voluntarily on committees and boards of local service and nonprofit organizations. Some also serve as members and consultants on professional committees and task forces that affect regional development in healthcare and education. MSHA does not capture costs associated with team members that serve on other nonprofit boards or provide services to other nonprofits.MSHA, in collaboration with area health agencies and providers, may offer assistance with coordination, advocacy, or contribute supplies to support groups for their program activities that serve to assist special populations within the area. Most of these organizations work to improve the lives of community members that have limited, or no, financial resources.MSHA provided sponsorships for the Lee County Redevelopment and Housing Authority, the Northeast Tennessee Regional Economic Partnership, the Founders Forge Leadership Development Program, and the Summit Leadership Foundation-Youth Leadership Program.
|
Part III, Line 2:
|
Self-pay balances include accounts after payments and contractual adjustments (discounts) have been applied from all third-party payers such as Medicare, TennCare/Medicaid, commercial insurers, and others - generally leaving the patient responsible for any remaining deductible and/or co-payment. Other self-pay accounts are from patients with no insurance or other third-party coverage. Under Ballad Health's system-wide self-pay policy, any patient who has no insurance and is ineligible for any government assistance program received an 85% discount. Many self-pay patients will further qualify for financial assistance (sometimes referred to as charity care) if they provide the financial information needed to deem them eligible or upon determination of presumptive charity eligibility. After the normal collection process has indicated an account is uncollectible, MSHA writes the account off to bad debt. The overall self-pay accounts receivable balance is evaluated on an ongoing basis to evaluate the age of accounts receivable, historical write-offs and recoveries and any unusual instances (such as local, regional or national economic conditions) which affect the collectability of receivables.
|
Part III, Line 3:
|
MSHA's primary external collection agency historically estimated that approximately 37% of MSHA's bad debt would have qualified for financial assistance if patients had provided a financial assistance application and required documentation. Pursuant to the merger, MSHA has begun to score accounts using a presumptive eligibility tool. This tool utilizes various data points for a proprietary algorithm operated by an outside vendor to provide an individual's score which is then relied upon to assign presumptive charity eligibility. There are many instances of patients with large account balances and no health insurance coverage that MSHA believes would qualify for financial assistance. Although patients are encouraged to apply for assistance, many will not do so. MSHA would prefer for patients to submit completed financial assistance applications given that historical data clearly indicates that most uninsured patients and many underinsured patients will qualify for financial assistance under our program. Without a completed application, these are recorded as bad debt instead of charity care.
|
Part III, Line 4:
|
Ballad Health's audited financial statements include a footnote on page 14 that describes bad debt. MSHA is included in the June 30, 2022 audited financial statements of Ballad Health (attached).
|
Part III, Line 8:
|
Excluding Medicare losses reported in Part I subsidized health, the Part III Medicare allowable costs are reported using MSHA's filed Medicare cost report (C/R). The C/R uses a cost to charge ratio based on a step-down allocation methodology. MSHA believes Medicare losses should be allowed as a reportable community benefit, similar to governmental programs such as Medicaid. As a participating provider in the Medicare program, hospitals are required to provide the full regimen of care for the Medicare population. There are a number of care regimens that are compensated by the Medicare program at levels below cost. Therefore, it is only logical to allow hospitals to report these uncompensated services as a community benefit. By making this change, nonprofit providers will be encouraged to continue important care delivery models for our aging population in spite of the fact it may be economically injurious.
|
Part III, Line 9b:
|
Requests for financial assistance are evaluated using established guidelines, while allowing for unique financial circumstances - for example, medically indigent patients with catastrophic medical costs that would threaten the patient's household financial viability. When a patient requests financial assistance or when an application has been received, the patient's account is placed in a hold status to prevent further collection activities until financial assistance eligibility is determined. All Ballad Health hospitals comply with IRS 501(r) regulatory guidelines.Ballad Health's collection policy clearly states that all patients are treated equally - with dignity and respect. Ballad Health ensures that outside collection agencies adhere to Ballad Health billing and collection guidelines. The collection program includes communicating expected financial responsibility prior to service. MSHA hospitals provide assistance to help underinsured and uninsured patients determine sources of payment for medical bills and to help patients determine eligibility for programs such as TennCare or Medicaid.After insurance benefit verification, MSHA hospitals bill insurance carriers. If the insurance carrier denies payment of the service/procedure as non-covered or the patient has exceeded their maximum benefits, the service/procedure will qualify for the uninsured discount.Financial counselors are available to discuss financial assistance with patients and their families. MSHA hospitals provide a number of payment options:- a pre-service discount may be offered- a discount in excess of established discounting rates may be granted for catastrophic high dollar accounts- MSHA hospitals accept all non-contracted and out-of-network payers and will make attempts to work with these payers regarding appropriate reimbursement and billing to their members- as part of Ballad Health's commitments to the State of Tennessee and Commonwealth of Virginia to form Ballad Health, not-in-network discounts are applied per policies in place for MSHA hospitals- payment arrangements are available as long as the account is not with a collection agencyReasonable efforts are made to determine if a patient is eligible for financial assistance - see Schedule H, Part VI, line 3 for information on how patients are informed about the Ballad Health financial assistance policy.
|
Part VI, Line 2:
|
Focusing on population health improvement and associated priority metrics allows Ballad Health to further engage the efforts of its hospitals in partnership with communities in our service areas. It has helped Ballad to better identify health disparities that appear across the individual communities and has helped Ballad to prioritize issues that are most important in each hospital's community. Engaging local community organizations expands partnerships so that organizations work together more to address community health needs. Ballad Health uses a comprehensive process to gather input for and continues to evolve its population health plan. Because our hospitals are located in a region with many chronic disease challenges and high levels of health-related social risks, Ballad Health's goal is to target population health issues to make lasting improvements. Ballad conducts ongoing interviews, focus groups and meetings with external groups, including the regional health departments, United Way agencies, chambers of commerce, schools and community organizations, the regional accountable care community leadership council, as well as internal groups such as our population health and community benefit committee of the Ballad Health board of directors, the Ballad Health population health clinical committee, social needs council, grant advisory committees and our hospital community boards in the creation and on-going implementation of its population health plan.
|
Part VI, Line 3:
|
Consistent with the Ballad Health financial assistance policy, MSHA communicates with and provides education to patients through various avenues regarding governmental assistance programs and hospital financial assistance. Various educational and application documents related to obtaining financial assistance are widely available at MSHA and all documents are available on the Ballad Health website. Printed financial assistance educational materials are part of each registration packet and posters are displayed in highly visible areas of the hospitals. Our financial assistance policy and documents are available in emergency departments and admitting areas. MSHA is also happy to mail all documents to patients and offers a plain language summary. All documents are available in English and Spanish. Financial assistance information is available during pre-registration, registration and/or during financial counseling. MSHA offers governmental program eligibility representatives to assist patients in securing eligibility for TennCare or Medicaid, federal disability and other governmental assistance programs. Additionally, if a patient or community resident expresses an interest in the ACA-healthcare exchange, MSHA representatives have the qualifications and experience to assist them through the entire process. Financial counselors offer financial assistance applications to patients who do not qualify for governmental assistance programs and are unable to pay for some or all of their healthcare.All patient billing statements have verbiage discussing financial assistance along with contact information. The last letter to the patient displays the plain language summary. In all oral correspondences with a patient, if it is identified the patient cannot meet payment requirements on their account, financial assistance is discussed as an option.Applicants are notified of financial assistance determination in writing.
|
Part VI, Line 4:
|
MSHA serves the healthcare needs of 29 Appalachian counties in Northeast Tennessee, Southwest Virginia, Southeast Kentucky, and Northwest North Carolina. All of the counties MSHA serves are federally designated as medically underserved areas. MSHA's largest hospital, Johnson City Medical Center, is a tertiary referral center and level one trauma center. Medically underserved areas are designated by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Shortage areas are identified through analysis of physician to population ratios depending on whether an area is considered to have a high need. Criteria used to determine high need are poverty rates, the percent of the population over age 65, infant mortality rates and fertility rates. MSHA operates 2 critical access hospitals: Johnson County Community Hospital in Tennessee and Lee County Community Hospital in Virginia.Additionally, according to the 2021 County Health Rankings, counties where MSHA hospitals are located ranked poorly for both health outcomes and health factors.
|
Part VI, Line 5:
|
MSHA is dedicated to operating efficiently so that waste is minimized. MSHA's leadership remains mindful of managing limited resources so that adequate facilities and equipment are available for the care of patients. Surplus funds are invested into improving treatment options for patients through new technologies, recruiting physicians and trained staff in shortage areas, and improving MSHA facilities. Various checks and balances are established to ensure that expenditures for operating expenses and capital costs are reasonable and necessary. MSHA has several hospitals with Medicare-approved health profession education programs. In addition, MSHA hospitals serve as training sites for many types of health professions: nursing, pharmacy, psychology, lab, respiratory therapy, EMT, public health, etc. Students from numerous colleges, universities, and programs receive training and experience in MSHA hospitals. MSHA resources are devoted to health conferences for local health professionals, two health resources centers conveniently located in a shopping mall and a wellness center; provide for media coverage to educate residents on health issues; offer events to the public that combine fun activities with health education; and many other programs focused on improving the health of area residents. While MSHA operates hospitals in predominantly low-income, rural and isolated areas, MSHA continues to offer services that operate at a loss because residents would otherwise need to leave their hometown or county to receive needed care. Mountain States merged with Wellmont Health System in February 2018 to form Ballad Health healthcare system. Mountain States and Wellmont still exist as legal entities and continue to operate multiple hospitals. MSHA's governing body is comprised of persons who reside in the organization's primary service areas. Physicians that request privileges who are qualified and credentialed are extended privileges by MSHA.
|
Part VI, Line 6:
|
Mountain State's merger with Wellmont opened up many opportunities not previously available to two competing health systems. Collaboration started post-merger and Ballad Health continues to see progress towards improving efficiencies within our health system, activities consistent with Ballad Health's population health initiative, sharing best practice quality improvements, and other benefits related to operating as one rather than operating in a competitive environment. A clinical council was formed immediately following the merger. The council includes physicians nominated from the leadership of all Ballad hospitals. A Community Benefit and Population Health Committee of the board was established, and various other infrastructures have been established since the merger. Across MSHA's hospitals, there were many projects, programs, and collaborative efforts that took place during the year. MSHA provides care to people in 29 counties in Tennessee, Virginia, Kentucky and North Carolina. Each hospital is fully accredited by The Joint Commission, with the exception of Johnson County Community Hospital and Lee County Community Hospital. JCCH and LCCH receive certification through the states of Tennessee and Virginia since they are critical access hospitals. MSHA, based in Johnson City, Tennessee includes 8 wholly owned hospitals which are included in this Form 990. In addition, MSHA owns 2 hospitals located in Southwest Virginia, each of which file separate returns. In addition to acute care hospitals, the system includes such services as:Primary/specialty physician practices, emergency departments, occupational medicine, rehabilitation, outreach laboratory, mental health, neonatal intensive care, a NACHARI-affiliated children's hospital, renal dialysis, St. Jude's Oncology, inpatient/outpatient surgery, skilled nursing, long-term care, home health, and more. With these additional facilities and services, MSHA extends a highly effective health care delivery system. Since our system is both horizontally and vertically integrated, patients can be efficiently moved along an integrated, comprehensive continuum of care as their health status dictates. MSHA's flagship facility, Johnson City Medical Center is at the core of the system offering full-service tertiary care. In addition to MSHA hospitals, MSHA is the sole member of Blue Ridge Medical Management Corporation (BRMMC). MSHA extends an integrated healthcare delivery system through BRMMC to include multiple primary and specialty care patient access centers and numerous outpatient care sites, including urgent care centers, occupational medicine services, a same day surgery center and rehabilitation.MSHA partners with East Tennessee State University to operate Overmountain Recovery, an opioid addiction recovery facility located in Gray, Tennessee.MSHA is the sole member of Integrated Solutions Health Network, LLC. (ISHN). ISHN operates Anewcare Collaborative, the region's first accountable care organization, bringing together community health care providers to provide better outcomes and improved patient satisfaction at a lower cost.Hospitals in the Ballad Health system work closely with one another to share expertise and resources.
|
Part VI, Line 7, Reports Filed With States
|
TN,VA
|
Part VI, Additional Information
|
Ballad Health is required to report community benefit estimates on a quarterly basis with the states of Tennessee and Virginia. The reporting includes all of Ballad Health's hospital organizations and is reported using IRS Form 990, Schedule H instructions for reporting community benefit. Ballad Health operates under a Certificate of Public Advantage (COPA) in Tennessee and a Cooperative Agreement (CA) in Virginia as obligated by agreements between Ballad Health and the two states to allow Mountain States Health Alliance and Wellmont Health System to merge.
|