PROPUBLICA Fearless Reporting for an Informed Society — Join Us.
DONATE
Skip to content
ProPublica Donate
ProPublica Donate

Caresource Indiana Inc

Organization summary

Type of Nonprofit

Designated as a Organizations for any of the following purposes: religious, educational, charitable, scientific, literary, testing for public safety, fostering national or international amateur sports competition (as long as it doesn't provide athletic facilities or equipment), or the prevention of cruelty to children or animals.

Category: Health — General and Rehabilitative / Health, General and Financing (NTEE)

Donations to this organization are tax deductible.

Summary charts: organization finances over time

Revenue
$1.22B (2023)

Expenses
$1.11B (2023)

Total Assets
$464M (2023)

Total Liabilities
$303M (2023)

Source: Form 990 tax filings from 2011 to 2023

Tax Filings by Year

Form 990 is an information return that most organizations claiming federal tax-exempt status must file yearly with the IRS. Nonprofit Explorer has IRS digitized Form 990 data for filings processed in 2012 and later. If this organization filed an amended return, it may not be reflected below. Duplicate download links may indicate a resubmission or amendment to this organization's original return. Form 990 data is from the IRS.

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2023

Extracted Financial Data

Extracted Financial Data from Form 990
Revenue
$1,218,667,752
Expenses
$1,112,999,592
Net Income
$105,668,160
Net Assets
$160,796,377
Notable Sources of Revenue Percent of Total Revenue
Contributions $0
Program Services $1,200,967,368
98.5%
Investment Income $18,026,945
1.5%
Bond Proceeds $0
Royalties $0
Rental Property Income $0
Net Fundraising $0
Sales of Assets -$326,561
Net Inventory Sales $0
Other Revenue $0
Notable Expenses Percent of Total Expenses
Executive Compensation $0
Professional Fundraising Fees $0
Other Salaries and Wages $0
Assets/Debt
Total Assets $463,855,622
Total Liabilities $303,059,245
Net Assets $160,796,377
Compensation
Key Employees and Officers Compensation Related Other
Erhardt Preitauer (Pres/Ceo To 4/23 Then Chr/Dir) $0 $7,982,382 $4,047,739
Richard Topping (Secretary (Eff 5/23)) $0 $2,429,434 $942,437
Lawrence Smart (Cfo, Treasurer/Dir (Eff 5/23)) $0 $2,282,374 $712,492
Scott Markovich (Director (To 5/23)) $0 $2,046,512 $861,652
Jai Pillai (Chief Operating Ofr (To 4/23)) $0 $1,975,288 $15,770
Steve Smitherman (President (Eff 5/23), Director) $0 $1,087,503 $550,961
Stephanie Williams (Dir (To 4/23) Then Asst Treas) $0 $874,375 $548,452
Daniel Mc Cabe (Former Chief Admin Officer) $0 $140,542 $0
William Coffin Jr (Former Vp Mkt Finance/Director) $0 $24,304 $0

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2022

Extracted Financial Data

Extracted Financial Data from Form 990
Revenue
$1,036,113,607
Expenses
$1,049,992,612
Net Income
-$13,879,005
Net Assets
$70,541,485
Notable Sources of Revenue Percent of Total Revenue
Contributions $0
Program Services $1,029,880,554
99.4%
Investment Income $6,306,470
0.6%
Bond Proceeds $0
Royalties $0
Rental Property Income $0
Net Fundraising $0
Sales of Assets -$73,417
Net Inventory Sales $0
Other Revenue $0
Notable Expenses Percent of Total Expenses
Executive Compensation $0
Professional Fundraising Fees $0
Other Salaries and Wages $0
Assets/Debt
Total Assets $478,256,817
Total Liabilities $407,715,332
Net Assets $70,541,485
Compensation
Key Employees and Officers Compensation Related Other
Erhardt Preitauer (President & Ceo) $0 $3,656,889 $4,253,649
Jai Pillai (Chief Operating Officer) $0 $1,235,514 $871,311
Lawrence Smart (Chief Financial Officer) $0 $1,072,888 $998,867
Scott Markovich (Evp Markets & Products, Dir) $0 $966,866 $950,975
Daniel Mc Cabe (Chief Admin Officer (To 4/22)) $0 $1,505,969 $14,895
Steve Smitherman (President Market, Director) $0 $637,575 $563,955
Stephanie Williams (Svp Ch Acty, Dir (Eff 4/22)) $0 $524,391 $577,351
William Coffin Jr (Vp Mkt Finance, Dir (To 4/22)) $0 $524,895 $22,301
David Finkel (Former Evp Markets, Director) $0 $194,579 $0

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2021

Extracted Financial Data

Extracted Financial Data from Form 990
Revenue
$990,208,142
Expenses
$963,967,552
Net Income
$26,240,590
Net Assets
$88,252,202
Notable Sources of Revenue Percent of Total Revenue
Contributions $0
Program Services $989,801,374
100.0%
Investment Income $406,768
0.0%
Bond Proceeds $0
Royalties $0
Rental Property Income $0
Net Fundraising $0
Sales of Assets $0
Net Inventory Sales $0
Other Revenue $0
Notable Expenses Percent of Total Expenses
Executive Compensation $0
Professional Fundraising Fees $0
Other Salaries and Wages $0
Assets/Debt
Total Assets $434,368,652
Total Liabilities $346,116,450
Net Assets $88,252,202
Compensation
Key Employees and Officers Compensation Related Other
Erhardt Preitauer (President & Ceo) $0 $7,853,709 $2,969,682
Jai Pillai (Chief Operating Officer) $0 $2,098,405 $787,344
Daniel Mc Cabe (Chief Administrative Officer) $0 $1,617,731 $608,113
David Finkel (Evp, Markets & Chair (To 4/21)) $0 $1,703,154 $11,601
David Goltz (Chief Financial Ofr (To 1/21)) $0 $1,556,240 $2,783
Scott Markovich (Evp, Mkts & Chair (Eff 4/21)) $0 $974,373 $532,340
Lawrence Smart (Chief Financial Ofr (Eff 1/21)) $0 $636,903 $708,351
Steve Smitherman (President, Market & Secretary) $0 $917,471 $385,606
William Coffin Jr (Vp Mkt Finance & Treasurer) $0 $640,317 $234,075
Pamela Morris (Former President & Ceo) $0 $646,015 $0

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2020

Extracted Financial Data

Extracted Financial Data from Form 990
Revenue
$751,111,177
Expenses
$744,908,345
Net Income
$6,202,832
Net Assets
$62,011,612
Notable Sources of Revenue Percent of Total Revenue
Contributions $0
Program Services $750,157,227
99.9%
Investment Income $953,950
0.1%
Bond Proceeds $0
Royalties $0
Rental Property Income $0
Net Fundraising $0
Sales of Assets $0
Net Inventory Sales $0
Other Revenue $0
Notable Expenses Percent of Total Expenses
Executive Compensation $0
Professional Fundraising Fees $0
Other Salaries and Wages $0
Assets/Debt
Total Assets $327,554,719
Total Liabilities $265,543,107
Net Assets $62,011,612
Compensation
Key Employees and Officers Compensation Related Other
Erhardt Preitauer (President & Ceo) $0 $2,239,483 $3,719,592
Jai Pillai (Chief Operating Officer) $0 $1,037,573 $910,643
David Finkel (Exec Vp, Markets & Chair/Dir) $0 $736,768 $797,538
David Goltz (Chief Financial Officer) $0 $949,833 $574,541
Daniel Mc Cabe (Chief Administrative Officer) $0 $809,693 $631,182
Steve Smitherman (Pres, Market & Sec/Director) $0 $510,600 $369,355
William Coffin Jr (Vp Market Finance & Treas/Dir) $0 $437,494 $295,148
Kevin Brown (Former Director) $0 $212,500 $0
Patricia Martin (Former Vice Chair) $0 $117,500 $0

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2019

Extracted Financial Data

Extracted Financial Data from Form 990
Revenue
$641,719,004
Expenses
$594,936,324
Net Income
$46,782,680
Net Assets
$85,808,780
Notable Sources of Revenue Percent of Total Revenue
Contributions $0
Program Services $640,981,578
99.9%
Investment Income $737,426
0.1%
Bond Proceeds $0
Royalties $0
Rental Property Income $0
Net Fundraising $0
Sales of Assets $0
Net Inventory Sales $0
Other Revenue $0
Notable Expenses Percent of Total Expenses
Executive Compensation $1,013,934
0.2%
Professional Fundraising Fees $0
Other Salaries and Wages $13,384,777
2.2%
Assets/Debt
Total Assets $241,392,526
Total Liabilities $155,583,746
Net Assets $85,808,780
Compensation
Key Employees and Officers Compensation Related Other
Steve Smitherman (President, Market/Sec/Treas) $778,465 $0 $235,469
Cameual Wright (Medical Dir, Market) $291,381 $0 $92,976
Betsy Jerome (Vp, Care4 U) $242,203 $0 $94,364
Elizabeth Mc Carty (Dir Pharmacy Ops) $210,869 $0 $75,004
Caitlin Finneganpriest (Dir Gov Relations) $169,943 $0 $48,809
David Rose (Dir In Pln Compl) $157,579 $0 $57,903
Erhardt Preitauer (President & Ceo) $0 $3,061,457 $1,899,707
David Goltz (Chief Financial Officer) $0 $1,395,705 $523,051
Jai Pillai (Chief Operating Officer) $0 $837,370 $495,728
David Finkel (Evp, Markets/Chairperson) $0 $826,297 $407,546
Daniel Mc Cabe (Chief Administrative Officer) $0 $737,231 $410,495
L Tarlton Thomas Iii (Former Chief Operating Officer) $0 $1,107,296 $3,517
William Coffin (Vp, Market Finance/Director) $0 $524,876 $144,232
Kevin Brown (Former Director) $0 $220,000 $0
Patricia Martin (Former Vice Chair) $0 $103,750 $0

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2018

Extracted Financial Data

Extracted Financial Data from Form 990
Revenue
$795,707,884
Expenses
$786,449,043
Net Income
$9,258,841
Net Assets
$48,745,934
Notable Sources of Revenue Percent of Total Revenue
Contributions $0
Program Services $793,585,249
99.7%
Investment Income $2,122,635
0.3%
Bond Proceeds $0
Royalties $0
Rental Property Income $0
Net Fundraising $0
Sales of Assets $0
Net Inventory Sales $0
Other Revenue $0
Notable Expenses Percent of Total Expenses
Executive Compensation $657,188
0.1%
Professional Fundraising Fees $0
Other Salaries and Wages $12,078,290
1.5%
Assets/Debt
Total Assets $231,216,052
Total Liabilities $182,470,118
Net Assets $48,745,934
Compensation
Key Employees and Officers Compensation Related Other
Steve Smitherman (President, Market) $371,262 $0 $285,926
Cameual Wright (Medical Director Market) $271,764 $0 $65,508
Elizabeth Mc Carty (Director Pharmacy Operations) $206,409 $0 $67,443
Betsy Jerome (Director Care4 U Indiana) $185,668 $0 $60,329
Caitlin Finneganpriest (Director Government Relations) $161,361 $0 $37,118
David Rose (Director Regulatory Market) $144,883 $0 $48,951
Kevin R Brown (Trustee) $0 $122,500 $0
Patricia Martin (Vice Chairperson/Trustee) $0 $50,000 $0
J Thomas Maultsby (Chairperson/Trustee) $0 $55,000 $0
Pamela B Morris (Pres/Ceo/Sec/Treas To 05/18) $0 $4,530,802 $21,301
Erhardt H Preitauer (Pres/Ceo/Sec/Treas From 05/18) $0 $941,905 $1,887,975
David W Goltz (Chief Financial Officer) $0 $687,051 $560,101
Daniel J Mc Cabe (Chief Administrative Officer) $0 $740,019 $350,808
L Tarlton Thomas Iii (Chief Operating Ofr To 09/18) $0 $904,830 $44,012
Jai P Pillai (Chief Operating Ofr From 09/18) $0 $212,672 $406,560

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2017

Extracted Financial Data

Extracted Financial Data from Form 990
Revenue
$358,614,607
Expenses
$350,778,188
Net Income
$7,836,419
Net Assets
$39,487,093
Notable Sources of Revenue Percent of Total Revenue
Contributions $0
Program Services $358,378,523
99.9%
Investment Income $236,084
0.1%
Bond Proceeds $0
Royalties $0
Rental Property Income $0
Net Fundraising $0
Sales of Assets $0
Net Inventory Sales $0
Other Revenue $0
Notable Expenses Percent of Total Expenses
Executive Compensation $338,643
0.1%
Professional Fundraising Fees $0
Other Salaries and Wages $0
Assets/Debt
Total Assets $166,668,255
Total Liabilities $127,181,162
Net Assets $39,487,093
Compensation
Key Employees and Officers Compensation Related Other
Steve Smitherman (Vp/Executive Director) $241,142 $0 $97,501
J Thomas Maultsby (Sec/Treas To 08/17; Chair) $0 $55,000 $0
Kevin R Brown (Trustee) $0 $136,250 $0
Patricia Martin (Vice Chair From 8/17; Trustee) $0 $50,000 $0
Pamela B Morris (Sec/Treas From 8/17; Pres/Ceo) $0 $3,626,452 $1,072,127
Craig Thiele Md (Chief Medical Officer To 6/17) $0 $1,248,029 $37,111
Daniel Mc Cabe (Chief Administrative Officer) $0 $811,840 $239,153
L Tarlton Thomas Iii (Chief Operating Officer) $0 $1,044,863 $285,766
David W Goltz (Chief Financial Ofr From 12/17) $0 $153,601 $775

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2016

Extracted Financial Data

Extracted Financial Data from Form 990
Revenue
$94,959,613
Expenses
$116,404,473
Net Income
-$21,444,860
Net Assets
$16,650,674
Notable Sources of Revenue Percent of Total Revenue
Contributions $0
Program Services $94,923,412
100.0%
Investment Income $36,201
0.0%
Bond Proceeds $0
Royalties $0
Rental Property Income $0
Net Fundraising $0
Sales of Assets $0
Net Inventory Sales $0
Other Revenue $0
Notable Expenses Percent of Total Expenses
Executive Compensation $293,035
0.3%
Professional Fundraising Fees $0
Other Salaries and Wages $0
Assets/Debt
Total Assets $68,699,557
Total Liabilities $52,048,883
Net Assets $16,650,674
Compensation
Key Employees and Officers Compensation Related Other
Steve Smitherman (Vp/Executive Director) $283,480 $0 $19,442
J Thomas Maultsby (Chair/Sec/Treas/Trustee) $0 $45,625 $0
Kevin R Brown (Trustee) $0 $55,625 $0
Patricia Martin (Trustee) $0 $40,000 $0
Pamela B Morris (President/Ceo/Trustee) $0 $2,217,770 $587,994
Craig Thiele Md (Chief Medical Officer) $0 $594,165 $45,447
Daniel Mc Cabe (Chief Administrative Officer) $0 $849,388 $130,442
L Tarlton Thomas Iii (Evp Operations & Cfo) $0 $670,319 $153,424
Bobby Jones To 62016 (President Georgia Market) $0 $788,788 $151,624

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2015

Extracted Financial Data

Extracted Financial Data from Form 990
Revenue
$57,072,388
Expenses
$62,817,229
Net Income
-$5,744,841
Net Assets
$8,095,534
Notable Sources of Revenue Percent of Total Revenue
Contributions $0
Program Services $57,071,760
100.0%
Investment Income $628
0.0%
Bond Proceeds $0
Royalties $0
Rental Property Income $0
Net Fundraising $0
Sales of Assets $0
Net Inventory Sales $0
Other Revenue $0
Notable Expenses Percent of Total Expenses
Executive Compensation $0
Professional Fundraising Fees $0
Other Salaries and Wages $0
Assets/Debt
Total Assets $52,383,997
Total Liabilities $44,288,463
Net Assets $8,095,534
Compensation
Key Employees and Officers Compensation Related Other
J Thomas Maultsby (Chair/Sec/Treas/Trustee) $0 $36,250 $0
Kevin R Brown (Trustee) $0 $43,750 $0
Patricia Martin (Trustee) $0 $30,000 $0
Pamela B Morris (President/Ceo/Trustee) $0 $5,908,941 $1,953,879
Craig Thiele Md (Chief Medical Officer) $0 $1,514,932 $385,779
Bobby Jones (Chief Operating Officer) $0 $1,744,871 $468,397
L Tarlton Thomas Iii (Chief Financial Officer) $0 $1,235,678 $405,217

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2014

Extracted Financial Data

Extracted Financial Data from Form 990
Revenue
$1,947
Expenses
$323,400
Net Income
-$321,453
Net Assets
$2,240,375
Notable Sources of Revenue Percent of Total Revenue
Contributions $0
Program Services $743
38.2%
Investment Income $1,204
61.8%
Bond Proceeds $0
Royalties $0
Rental Property Income $0
Net Fundraising $0
Sales of Assets $0
Net Inventory Sales $0
Other Revenue $0
Notable Expenses Percent of Total Expenses
Executive Compensation $0
Professional Fundraising Fees $0
Other Salaries and Wages $0
Assets/Debt
Total Assets $2,974,336
Total Liabilities $733,961
Net Assets $2,240,375
Compensation
Key Employees and Officers Compensation Related Other
J Thomas Maultsby (Chair/Sec/Treas/Trustee) $0 $6,250 $0
Kevin R Brown (Trustee) $0 $43,750 $0
Steven Smitherman To 1214 (Trustee) $0 $0 $0
Pamela B Morris (President/Ceo/Trustee) $0 $1,844,762 $1,298,775
Craig Thiele Md (Chief Medical Officer) $0 $674,507 $307,473
Bobby Jones (Chief Operating Officer) $0 $752,934 $358,224
L Tarlton Thomas Iii (Chief Financial Officer) $0 $534,616 $292,101

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2013

Extracted Financial Data

Extracted Financial Data from Form 990
Revenue
$3,225
Expenses
$46,129
Net Income
-$42,904
Net Assets
$1,561,828
Notable Sources of Revenue Percent of Total Revenue
Contributions $0
Program Services $3,225
100%
Investment Income $0
Bond Proceeds $0
Royalties $0
Rental Property Income $0
Net Fundraising $0
Sales of Assets $0
Net Inventory Sales $0
Other Revenue $0
Notable Expenses Percent of Total Expenses
Executive Compensation $0
Professional Fundraising Fees $0
Other Salaries and Wages $0
Assets/Debt
Total Assets $1,570,139
Total Liabilities $8,311
Net Assets $1,561,828
Compensation
Key Employees and Officers Compensation Related Other
J Thomas Maultsby (Chair/Sec/Treas/Trustee) $0 $0 $0
Kevin R Brown (Trustee) $0 $30,500 $0
Steven Smitherman From 1213 (Trustee) $0 $0 $0
Pamela B Morris (President/Ceo/Trustee) $0 $1,664,314 $1,040,994
Craig Thiele Md (Chief Medial Officer) $0 $673,263 $237,793
Bobby Jones (Chief Operating Officer) $0 $1,146,255 $253,693
L Tarlton Thomas Iii (Chief Financial Officer) $0 $425,661 $219,710

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2012

Extracted Financial Data

Extracted Financial Data from Form 990
Revenue
$10,822
Expenses
$15,853
Net Income
-$5,031
Net Assets
$1,904,732
Notable Sources of Revenue Percent of Total Revenue
Contributions $0
Program Services $10,202
94.3%
Investment Income $620
5.7%
Bond Proceeds $0
Royalties $0
Rental Property Income $0
Net Fundraising $0
Sales of Assets $0
Net Inventory Sales $0
Other Revenue $0
Notable Expenses Percent of Total Expenses
Executive Compensation $0
Professional Fundraising Fees $0
Other Salaries and Wages $0
Assets/Debt
Total Assets $1,912,737
Total Liabilities $8,005
Net Assets $1,904,732

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2011

Extracted Financial Data

Extracted Financial Data from Form 990
Revenue
$28,019
Expenses
$17,521
Net Income
$10,498
Net Assets
$1,909,763
Notable Sources of Revenue Percent of Total Revenue
Contributions $0
Program Services $27,769
99.1%
Investment Income $250
0.9%
Bond Proceeds $0
Royalties $0
Rental Property Income $0
Net Fundraising $0
Sales of Assets $0
Net Inventory Sales $0
Other Revenue $0
Notable Expenses Percent of Total Expenses
Executive Compensation $0
Professional Fundraising Fees $0
Other Salaries and Wages $0
Assets/Debt
Total Assets $1,915,877
Total Liabilities $6,114
Net Assets $1,909,763

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2010

No Extracted Financial Data

Extracted financial data is not available for the forms filed in this tax period, but Form 990 documents are available for download.

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2009

No Extracted Financial Data

Extracted financial data is not available for the forms filed in this tax period, but Form 990 documents are available for download.

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2008

No Extracted Financial Data

Extracted financial data is not available for the forms filed in this tax period, but Form 990 documents are available for download.

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2007

No Extracted Financial Data

Extracted financial data is not available for the forms filed in this tax period, but Form 990 documents are available for download.

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2006

No Extracted Financial Data

Extracted financial data is not available for the forms filed in this tax period, but Form 990 documents are available for download.

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2005

No Extracted Financial Data

Extracted financial data is not available for the forms filed in this tax period, but Form 990 documents are available for download.

Document Links

Fiscal Year Ending Dec.
2004

No Extracted Financial Data

Extracted financial data is not available for the forms filed in this tax period, but Form 990 documents are available for download.

Document Links

About This Data

Nonprofit Explorer includes summary data for nonprofit tax returns and full Form 990 documents, in both PDF and digital formats.

The summary data contains information processed by the IRS during the 2012-2019 calendar years; this generally consists of filings for the 2011-2018 fiscal years, but may include older records. This data release includes only a subset of what can be found in the full Form 990s.

In addition to the raw summary data, we link to PDFs and digital copies of full Form 990 documents wherever possible. This consists of separate releases by the IRS of Form 990 documents processed by the agency, which we update regularly.

We also link to copies of audits nonprofit organizations that spent $750,000 or more in Federal grant money in a single fiscal year since 2016. These audits are copied from the Federal Audit Clearinghouse.

Which Organizations Are Here?

Every organization that has been recognized as tax exempt by the IRS has to file Form 990 every year, unless they make less than $200,000 in revenue and have less than $500,000 in assets, in which case they have to file form 990-EZ. Organizations making less than $50,000 don’t have to file either form but do have to let the IRS they’re still in business via a Form 990N "e-Postcard."

Nonprofit Explorer has organizations claiming tax exemption in each of the 27 subsections of the 501(c) section of the tax code, and which have filed a Form 990, Form 990EZ or Form 990PF. Taxable trusts and private foundations that are required to file a form 990PF are also included. Small organizations filing a Form 990N "e-Postcard" are not included in this data.

Types of Nonprofits

There are 27 nonprofit designations based on the numbered subsections of section 501(c) of the tax code. See the list »

Get the Data

For those interested in acquiring the original data from the source, here’s where our data comes from:

  • Raw filing data. Includes EINs and summary financials as structured data.
  • Exempt Organization profiles. Includes organization names, addresses, etc. You can merge this with the raw filing data using EIN numbers.
  • Form 990 documents. Prior to 2017, these documents were obtained and processed by Public.Resource.org and ProPublica. Bulk PDF downloads since 2017 are available from the IRS.
  • Form 990 documents as XML files. Includes complete filing data (financial details, names of officers, tax schedules, etc.) in machine-readable format. Only available for electronically filed documents. Electronic data released prior to October 2021 is also available through Amazon Web Services.
  • Audits. PDFs of single or program-specific audits for nonprofit organizations that spent $750,000 or more in Federal grant money in a single fiscal year. Available for fiscal year 2015 and later.

API

The data powering this website is available programmatically, via an API. Read the API documentation »