House Vote 88 - On Motion to Recommit with Instructions

Description:	Immigration Act of 1995
Result:	Failed by a margin of 22 votes (simple majority required to pass)
Date:	March 21, 1996 at 8:05 p.m. EST (vote source)

	R	D	Total
Yes	14	173	188	173 14 1
No	219	12	231	12 219
Other*	3	10	13	10 3

*Includes members who did not vote or voted "present"

Complete Roll Call

Explanation available

Mistaken vote

Yes Votes (188)

Member	Party	Dist.
Neil Abercrombie	D	HI-1
Gary L. Ackerman	D	NY-5
Robert E. Andrews	D	NJ-1
Scotty Baesler	D	KY-6
John Baldacci	D	ME-2
James A. Barcia	D	MI-5
Thomas M. Barrett	D	WI-5
Xavier Becerra	D	CA-30
Anthony C. Beilenson	D	CA-24
Ken Bentsen	D	TX-25
Howard L. Berman	D	CA-26
Sanford D. Bishop Jr.	D	GA-2
Sherwood L. Boehlert	R	NY-23
David E. Bonior	D	MI-10
Robert A. Borski	D	PA-3
Rick Boucher	D	VA-9
Glen Browder	D	AL-3
George E. Brown	D	CA-42
Corrine Brown	D	FL-3
Sherrod Brown	D	OH-13
John W. Bryant	D	TX-5
Benjamin L. Cardin	D	MD-3
Jim Chapman	D	TX-1
Eva Clayton	D	NC-1
James E. Clyburn	D	SC-6
Ronald D. Coleman	D	TX-16
Barbara-Rose Collins	D	MI-15
Gary Condit	D	CA-18
John Conyers Jr.	D	MI-14
Jerry F. Costello	D	IL-12
William J. Coyne	D	PA-14
Pat Danner	D	MO-6
Eligio 'Kiki' de la Garza	D	TX-15
Peter A. DeFazio	D	OR-4
Rosa DeLauro	D	CT-3
Ronald V. Dellums	D	CA-9
Peter Deutsch	D	FL-20
Norman D. Dicks	D	WA-6
John D. Dingell	D	MI-16
Julian C. Dixon	D	CA-32
Lloyd Doggett	D	TX-10
Mike Doyle	D	PA-18
Richard J. Durbin	D	IL-20
Chet Edwards	D	TX-11
Eliot L. Engel	D	NY-17
John Ensign	R	NV-1
Lane A. Evans	D	IL-17
Sam Farr	D	CA-17
Chaka Fattah	D	PA-2
Vic Fazio	D	CA-3
Cleo Fields	D	LA-4
Bob Filner	D	CA-50
Floyd H. Flake	D	NY-6
Tom Foglietta	D	PA-1
Harold E. Ford	D	TN-9
Barney Frank	D	MA-4
Rodney Frelinghuysen	R	NJ-11
Martin Frost	D	TX-24
Elizabeth Furse	D	OR-1
Sam Gejdenson	D	CT-2
Richard Andrew Gephardt	D	MO-3
Sam Gibbons	D	FL-11
Henry B. Gonzalez	D	TX-20
Bart Gordon	D	TN-6
Gene Green	D	TX-29
Luis V. Gutiérrez	D	IL-4
Tony P. Hall	D	OH-3
Lee H. Hamilton	D	IN-9
Jane Harman	D	CA-36
Alcee L. Hastings	D	FL-23
Bill Hefner	D	NC-8
Earl F. Hilliard	D	AL-7
Maurice D. Hinchey	D	NY-26
Tim Holden	D	PA-6
Steny H. Hoyer	D	MD-5
Jesse L. Jackson Jr.	D	IL-2
Sheila Jackson-Lee	D	TX-18
Andrew Jacobs Jr.	D	IN-10
William J. Jefferson	D	LA-2
Tim Johnson	D	SD-1
Eddie Bernice Johnson	D	TX-30
Paul E. Kanjorski	D	PA-11
Marcy Kaptur	D	OH-9
Joseph P. Kennedy II	D	MA-8
Patrick J. Kennedy	D	RI-1
Barbara B. Kennelly	D	CT-1
Dale E. Kildee	D	MI-9
Gerald D. Kleczka	D	WI-4
Ron Klink	D	PA-4
John J. LaFalce	D	NY-29
Tom Lantos	D	CA-12
Sander M. Levin	D	MI-12
John Lewis	D	GA-5
Blanche Lincoln	D	AR-1
William O. Lipinski	D	IL-3
Frank A. LoBiondo	R	NJ-2
Nita M. Lowey	D	NY-18
Bill Luther	D	MN-6
Carolyn B. Maloney	D	NY-14
Thomas J. Manton	D	NY-7
Edward J. Markey	D	MA-7
Matthew G. Martinez	D	CA-31
Frank Mascara	D	PA-20
Robert T. Matsui	D	CA-5
Karen McCarthy	D	MO-5
Jim McDermott	D	WA-7
Paul McHale	D	PA-15
Cynthia McKinney	D	GA-11
Michael R. McNulty	D	NY-21
Martin T. Meehan	D	MA-5
Carrie P. Meek	D	FL-17
Robert Menendez	D	NJ-13
Jack Metcalf	R	WA-2
Jan Meyers	R	KS-3
George Miller	D	CA-7
David Minge	D	MN-2
Patsy T. Mink	D	HI-2
Alan B. Mollohan	D	WV-1
James P. Moran	D	VA-8
John P. Murtha	D	PA-12
Jerrold Nadler	D	NY-8
Richard E. Neal	D	MA-2
Robert William Ney	R	OH-18
James L. Oberstar	D	MN-8
David R. Obey	D	WI-7
John W. Olver	D	MA-1
Solomon P. Ortiz	D	TX-27
Major R. Owens	D	NY-11
Frank Pallone	D	NJ-6
Ed Pastor	D	AZ-2
Donald M. Payne	D	NJ-10
Lewis F. Payne Jr.	D	VA-5
Nancy Pelosi	D	CA-8
Douglas Brian Peterson	D	FL-2
Collin C. Peterson	D	MN-7
Owen B. Pickett	D	VA-2
Earl Pomeroy	D	ND-1
Glenn Poshard	D	IL-19
Nick J. Rahall II	D	WV-3
Charles B. Rangel	D	NY-15
Jack Reed	D	RI-2
Ralph Regula	R	OH-16
Bill Richardson	D	NM-3
Lynn N. Rivers	D	MI-13
Tim Roemer	D	IN-3
Marge Roukema	R	NJ-5
Lucille Roybal-Allard	D	CA-33
Ed Royce	R	CA-39
Bobby L. Rush	D	IL-1
Martin Olav Sabo	D	MN-5
Bernard Sanders	ID	VT-1
Tom Sawyer	D	OH-14
Patricia Scott Schroeder	D	CO-1
Charles E. Schumer	D	NY-9
Robert C. Scott	D	VA-3
José E. Serrano	D	NY-16
Norman Sisisky	D	VA-4
David E. Skaggs	D	CO-2
Ike Skelton	D	MO-4
Louise M. Slaughter	D	NY-28
Christopher H. Smith	R	NJ-4
John M. Spratt Jr.	D	SC-5
Steve Stockman	R	TX-9
Bart Stupak	D	MI-1
John Tanner	D	TN-8
Gene Taylor	D	MS-5
Frank Tejeda	D	TX-28
Bennie Thompson	D	MS-2
Raymond Hoyt Thornton	D	AR-2
Karen L. Thurman	D	FL-5
Peter Gerard Torkildsen	R	MA-6
Esteban Edward Torres	D	CA-34
Robert G. Torricelli	D	NJ-9
Edolphus Towns	D	NY-10
James A. Traficant Jr.	D	OH-17
Nydia M. Velázquez	D	NY-12
Bruce F. Vento	D	MN-4
Peter J. Visclosky	D	IN-1
Harold Lee Volkmer	D	MO-9
Michael Delavan Ward	D	KY-3
Melvin Watt	D	NC-12
Henry A. Waxman	D	CA-29
John Patrick Williams	D	MT-1
Robert E. Wise Jr.	D	WV-2
Lynn Woolsey	D	CA-6
Albert Russell Wynn	D	MD-4
Sidney R. Yates	D	IL-9
Richard Zimmer	R	NJ-12

No Votes (231)

Member	Party	Dist.
Wayne A. Allard	R	CO-4
Bill Archer	R	TX-7
Richard K. Armey	R	TX-26
Spencer Bachus	R	AL-6
Bill Baker	R	CA-10
Richard Hugh Baker	R	LA-6
Cass Ballenger	R	NC-10
Bob Barr	R	GA-7
Bill Barrett	R	NE-3
Roscoe G. Bartlett	R	MD-6
Joe L. Barton	R	TX-6
Charles F. Bass	R	NH-2
Herbert H. Bateman	R	VA-1
Douglas K. Bereuter	R	NE-1
Tom Bevill	D	AL-4
Brian P. Bilbray	R	CA-49
Michael Bilirakis	R	FL-9
Tom Bliley	R	VA-7
Peter I. Blute	R	MA-3
John A. Boehner	R	OH-8
Henry Bonilla	R	TX-23
Sonny Bono	R	CA-44
Bill K. Brewster	D	OK-3
Sam Brownback	R	KS-2
Ed Bryant	R	TN-7
Jim Bunn	R	OR-5
Jim Bunning	R	KY-4
Richard M. Burr	R	NC-5
Dan Burton	R	IN-6
Steve Buyer	R	IN-5
Sonny Callahan	R	AL-1
Ken Calvert	R	CA-43
Dave Camp	R	MI-4
Tom Campbell	R	CA-15
Charles T. Canady	R	FL-12
Michael N. Castle	R	DE-1
Steven J. Chabot	R	OH-1
Saxby Chambliss	R	GA-8
Helen Chenoweth-Hage	R	ID-1
Jon Christensen	R	NE-2
Dick Chrysler	R	MI-8
Bob Clement	D	TN-5
William F. Clinger Jr.	R	PA-5
Howard Coble	R	NC-6
Tom Coburn	R	OK-2
Michael Allen Collins	R	GA-3
Larry Combest	R	TX-19
Wes Cooley	R	OR-2
Christopher Cox	R	CA-47
Robert E. Cramer	D	AL-5
Philip M. Crane	R	IL-8
Michael D. Crapo	R	ID-2
Frank Cremeans	R	OH-6
Barbara L. Cubin	R	WY-1
Randy 'Duke' Cunningham	R	CA-51
Thomas M. Davis	R	VA-11
Nathan Deal	R	GA-9
Lincoln Diaz-Balart	R	FL-21
Jay Dickey	R	AR-4
Calvin M. Dooley	D	CA-20
John T. Doolittle	R	CA-4
Robert K. Dornan	R	CA-46
David Dreier	R	CA-28
John J. Duncan Jr.	R	TN-2
Jennifer B. Dunn	R	WA-8
Vernon J. Ehlers	R	MI-3
Robert L. Ehrlich	R	MD-2
Jo Ann Emerson	R	MO-8
Phil English	R	PA-21
Anna G. Eshoo	D	CA-14
Terry Everett	R	AL-2
Thomas W. Ewing	R	IL-15
Harris W. Fawell	R	IL-13
Jack Milton Fields	R	TX-8
Michael P. Flanagan	R	IL-5
Mark Adam Foley	R	FL-16
Michael P. Forbes	R	NY-1
Tillie K. Fowler	R	FL-4
Jon D. Fox	R	PA-13
Gary A. Franks	R	CT-5
Bob Franks	R	NJ-7
Dan Frisa	R	NY-4
David Funderburk	R	NC-2
Elton Gallegly	R	CA-23
Greg Ganske	R	IA-4
George W. Gekas	R	PA-17
Pete Geren	D	TX-12
Wayne T. Gilchrest	R	MD-1
Paul E. Gillmor	R	OH-5
Benjamin A. Gilman	R	NY-20
Robert W. Goodlatte	R	VA-6
William F. Goodling	R	PA-19
Porter J. Goss	R	FL-14
Lindsey Graham	R	SC-3
James C. Greenwood	R	PA-8
Steve Gunderson	R	WI-3
Gilbert W. Gutknecht	R	MN-1
Ralph M. Hall	D	TX-4
Melton D. Hancock	R	MO-7
James V. Hansen	R	UT-1
J. Dennis Hastert	R	IL-14
Doc Hastings	R	WA-4
James A. Hayes	R	LA-7
John D. Hayworth	R	AZ-6
Joel Hefley	R	CO-5
Fred Heineman	R	NC-4
Wally Herger	R	CA-2
Van Hilleary	R	TN-4
David Lee Hobson	R	OH-7
Peter Hoekstra	R	MI-2
Martin R. Hoke	R	OH-10
Stephen Horn	R	CA-38
John Nathan Hostettler	R	IN-8
Amory Houghton	R	NY-31
Duncan L. Hunter	R	CA-52
Tim Hutchinson	R	AR-3
Henry John Hyde	R	IL-6
Bob Inglis	R	SC-4
Ernest J. Istook	R	OK-5
Nancy Lee Johnson	R	CT-6
Sam Johnson	R	TX-3
Walter B. Jones	R	NC-3
John R. Kasich	R	OH-12
Sue W. Kelly	R	NY-19
Jay Kim	R	CA-41
Peter T. King	R	NY-3
Jack Kingston	R	GA-1
Scott L. Klug	R	WI-2
Joseph K. Knollenberg	R	MI-11
James T. Kolbe	R	AZ-5
Ray H. LaHood	R	IL-18
Steve Largent	R	OK-1
Tom Latham	R	IA-5
Steven C. LaTourette	R	OH-19
Gregory H. Laughlin	R	TX-14
Rick Lazio	R	NY-2
James A. Leach	R	IA-1
Jerry Lewis	R	CA-40
Ron Lewis	R	KY-2
James Ross Lightfoot	R	IA-3
John Linder	R	GA-4
Bob Livingston	R	LA-1
Zoe Lofgren	D	CA-16
James Longley	R	ME-1
Frank D. Lucas	R	OK-6
Donald Manzullo	R	IL-16
William J. Martini	R	NJ-8
Bill McCollum	R	FL-8
Jim O. McCrery	R	LA-5
Joseph M. McDade	R	PA-10
John M. McHugh	R	NY-24
Scott McInnis	R	CO-3
David M. McIntosh	R	IN-2
Howard P. McKeon	R	CA-25
John L. Mica	R	FL-7
Dan Miller	R	FL-13
Susan Molinari	R	NY-13
Sonny Montgomery	D	MS-3
Carlos John Moorhead	R	CA-27
Constance A. Morella	R	MD-8
John T. Myers	R	IN-7
Sue Myrick	R	NC-9
George R. Nethercutt	R	WA-5
Mark W. Neumann	R	WI-1
Charles W. Norwood	R	GA-10
James Allen Nussle	R	IA-2
William Orton	D	UT-3
Michael G. Oxley	R	OH-4
Ron Packard	R	CA-48
Mike Parker	R	MS-4
Bill Paxon	R	NY-27
Tom Petri	R	WI-6
Richard W. Pombo	R	CA-11
John Edward Porter	R	IL-10
Rob Portman	R	OH-2
Deborah D. Pryce	R	OH-15
James Henry Quillen	R	TN-1
Jack Quinn	R	NY-30
James M. Ramstad	R	MN-3
Frank Riggs	R	CA-1
Pat Roberts	R	KS-1
Harold Rogers	R	KY-5
Dana Rohrabacher	R	CA-45
Ileana Ros-Lehtinen	R	FL-18
Toby A. Roth	R	WI-8
Matt Salmon	R	AZ-1
Mark Sanford	R	SC-1
H. James Saxton	R	NJ-3
Joe Scarborough	R	FL-1
Dan Schaefer	R	CO-6
Steven Schiff	R	NM-1
Andrea Seastrand	R	CA-22
F. James Sensenbrenner	R	WI-9
John Shadegg	R	AZ-4
E. Clay Shaw	R	FL-22
Christopher H. Shays	R	CT-4
Bud Shuster	R	PA-9
Joe Skeen	R	NM-2
Nick Smith	R	MI-7
Lamar Smith	R	TX-21
Linda Smith	R	WA-3
Gerald B.H. Solomon	R	NY-22
Mark Souder	R	IN-4
Floyd Spence	R	SC-2
Cliff Stearns	R	FL-6
Charles W. Stenholm	D	TX-17
Bob Stump	R	AZ-3
James M. Talent	R	MO-2
Randy J. Tate	R	WA-9
William J. Tauzin	R	LA-3
Charles H. Taylor	R	NC-11
William M. Thomas	R	CA-21
William M. Thornberry	R	TX-13
Todd Tiahrt	R	KS-4
Fred Upton	R	MI-6
Barbara Farrell Vucanovich	R	NV-2
Enid Greene Waldholtz	R	UT-2
Robert Smith Walker	R	PA-16
James T. Walsh	R	NY-25
Zach Wamp	R	TN-3
J.C. Watts	R	OK-4
David J. Weldon	R	FL-15
W. Curtis Weldon	R	PA-7
Gerald C. Weller	R	IL-11
Rick White	R	WA-1
Edward Whitfield	R	KY-1
Roger Wicker	R	MS-1
Frank R. Wolf	R	VA-10
Don Young	R	AK-1
C. W. Bill Young	R	FL-10
William H. Zeliff	R	NH-1

Did Not Vote (12)

Member	Party	Dist.
William Clay	D	MO-1
Cardiss Collins	D	IL-7
Thomas Dale DeLay	R	TX-22
Newt Gingrich	R	GA-6
Harry A. Johnston	D	FL-19
Joe Moakley	D	MA-9
George P. Radanovich	R	CA-19
Charles Grandison Rose	D	NC-7
Pete Stark	D	CA-13
Louis Stokes	D	OH-11
Gerry Eastman Studds	D	MA-10
Maxine Waters	D	CA-35
Charles Wilson	D	TX-2

* By tradition, the Speaker of the House votes at his or her discretion. In cases where the Speaker does not vote, that absence is not counted in the "Not Voting" totals displayed here, but Represent adds the Speaker's name to the list of people who did not vote.

Legislators

Bills

Statements

Lobbying

Travel

Yes Votes (188)

No Votes (231)

Did Not Vote (12)