House Vote 358 - On Agreeing to the Amendment

Bill:
Description: Goodlatte (VA) Amendment to Shays (CT) Substitute
Result: Failed by a margin of 48 votes (simple majority required to pass)
Date: ()
R D Total
Yes 163 
165
2
163
 
No 59 
200 
260
200
59
1
 
Other*
10
4
6
 
*Includes members who did not vote or voted "present"

Complete Roll Call

Explanation available
Mistaken vote

Yes Votes (165)

Member Party Dist.
 
Robert B. Aderholt
R AL-4
 
Bill Archer
R TX-7
 
Richard K. Armey
R TX-26
 
Spencer Bachus
R AL-6
 
Richard Hugh Baker
R LA-6
 
Cass Ballenger
R NC-10
 
Bob Barr
R GA-7
 
Roscoe G. Bartlett
R MD-6
 
Joe L. Barton
R TX-6
 
Herbert H. Bateman
R VA-1
 
Douglas K. Bereuter
R NE-1
 
Michael Bilirakis
R FL-9
 
Tom Bliley
R VA-7
 
Roy Blunt
R MO-7
 
John A. Boehner
R OH-8
 
Henry Bonilla
R TX-23
 
Sonny Bono
R CA-44
 
Ed Bryant
R TN-7
 
Jim Bunning
R KY-4
 
Richard M. Burr
R NC-5
 
Dan Burton
R IN-6
 
Steve Buyer
R IN-5
 
Sonny Callahan
R AL-1
 
Ken Calvert
R CA-43
 
Dave Camp
R MI-4
 
Charles T. Canady
R FL-12
 
Christopher B. Cannon
R UT-3
 
Saxby Chambliss
R GA-8
 
Jon Christensen
R NE-2
 
Howard Coble
R NC-6
 
Tom Coburn
R OK-2
 
Michael Allen Collins
R GA-3
 
Larry Combest
R TX-19
 
John Cooksey
R LA-5
 
Christopher Cox
R CA-47
 
Philip M. Crane
R IL-8
 
Barbara L. Cubin
R WY-1
 
Randy 'Duke' Cunningham
R CA-51
 
Thomas M. Davis
R VA-11
 
Nathan Deal
R GA-9
 
Thomas Dale DeLay
R TX-22
 
Jay Dickey
R AR-4
 
John T. Doolittle
R CA-4
 
David Dreier
R CA-28
 
John J. Duncan Jr.
R TN-2
 
Jennifer B. Dunn
R WA-8
 
Vernon J. Ehlers
R MI-3
 
Robert L. Ehrlich
R MD-2
 
Jo Ann Emerson
R MO-8
 
John Ensign
R NV-1
 
Terry Everett
R AL-2
 
Thomas W. Ewing
R IL-15
 
Harris W. Fawell
R IL-13
 
Mark Adam Foley
R FL-16
 
Vito J. Fossella
R NY-13
 
Tillie K. Fowler
R FL-4
 
Elton Gallegly
R CA-23
 
George W. Gekas
R PA-17
 
James A. Gibbons
R NV-2
 
Robert W. Goodlatte
R VA-6
 
William F. Goodling
R PA-19
 
Porter J. Goss
R FL-14
 
Lindsey Graham
R SC-3
 
Kay Granger
R TX-12
 
Gilbert W. Gutknecht
R MN-1
 
James V. Hansen
R UT-1
 
J. Dennis Hastert
R IL-14
 
Doc Hastings
R WA-4
 
John D. Hayworth
R AZ-6
 
Joel Hefley
R CO-5
 
Wally Herger
R CA-2
 
Van Hilleary
R TN-4
 
David Lee Hobson
R OH-7
 
Peter Hoekstra
R MI-2
 
Stephen Horn
R CA-38
 
John Nathan Hostettler
R IN-8
 
Kenny C. Hulshof
R MO-9
 
Duncan L. Hunter
R CA-52
 
Henry John Hyde
R IL-6
 
Bob Inglis
R SC-4
 
William Lewis Jenkins
R TN-1
 
Sam Johnson
R TX-3
 
Walter B. Jones
R NC-3
 
John R. Kasich
R OH-12
 
Jack Kingston
R GA-1
 
Joseph K. Knollenberg
R MI-11
 
James T. Kolbe
R AZ-5
 
Ray H. LaHood
R IL-18
 
Steve Largent
R OK-1
 
Tom Latham
R IA-5
 
Jerry Lewis
R CA-40
 
Ron Lewis
R KY-2
 
William O. Lipinski
D IL-3
 
Bob Livingston
R LA-1
 
Frank D. Lucas
R OK-6
 
Bill McCollum
R FL-8
 
Jim O. McCrery
R LA-4
 
John M. McHugh
R NY-24
 
Scott McInnis
R CO-3
 
David M. McIntosh
R IN-2
 
Howard P. McKeon
R CA-25
 
John L. Mica
R FL-7
 
Dan Miller
R FL-13
 
Jerry Moran
R KS-1
 
Sue Myrick
R NC-9
 
George R. Nethercutt
R WA-5
 
Mark W. Neumann
R WI-1
 
Robert William Ney
R OH-18
 
Charles W. Norwood
R GA-10
 
James Allen Nussle
R IA-2
 
Michael G. Oxley
R OH-4
 
Ron Packard
R CA-48
 
Bill Paxon
R NY-27
 
Edward A. Pease
R IN-7
 
John E. Peterson
R PA-5
 
Charles W. Pickering
R MS-3
 
Joe Pitts
R PA-16
 
Richard W. Pombo
R CA-11
 
Deborah D. Pryce
R OH-15
 
George P. Radanovich
R CA-19
 
Bill Redmond
R NM-3
 
Bob Riley
R AL-3
 
James E. Rogan
R CA-27
 
Harold Rogers
R KY-5
 
Dana Rohrabacher
R CA-45
 
Ed Royce
R CA-39
 
Jim R. Ryun
R KS-2
 
Matt Salmon
R AZ-1
 
Joe Scarborough
R FL-1
 
Dan Schaefer
R CO-6
 
F. James Sensenbrenner
R WI-9
 
Pete Sessions
R TX-5
 
John Shadegg
R AZ-4
 
E. Clay Shaw
R FL-22
 
John Shimkus
R IL-20
 
Bud Shuster
R PA-9
 
Joe Skeen
R NM-2
 
Nick Smith
R MI-7
 
Robert F. Smith
R OR-2
 
Lamar Smith
R TX-21
 
Vince Snowbarger
R KS-3
 
Gerald B.H. Solomon
R NY-22
 
Floyd Spence
R SC-2
 
Cliff Stearns
R FL-6
 
Bob Stump
R AZ-3
 
James M. Talent
R MO-2
 
William J. Tauzin
R LA-3
 
Charles H. Taylor
R NC-11
 
William M. Thomas
R CA-21
 
William M. Thornberry
R TX-13
 
John Thune
R SD-1
 
Todd Tiahrt
R KS-4
 
James A. Traficant Jr.
D OH-17
 
Fred Upton
R MI-6
 
Zach Wamp
R TN-3
 
Wes Watkins
R OK-3
 
J.C. Watts
R OK-4
 
David J. Weldon
R FL-15
 
W. Curtis Weldon
R PA-7
 
Gerald C. Weller
R IL-11
 
Edward Whitfield
R KY-1
 
Roger Wicker
R MS-1
 
Heather A. Wilson
R NM-1
 
Frank R. Wolf
R VA-10
 
Don Young
R AK-1

No Votes (260)

Member Party Dist.
 
Neil Abercrombie
D HI-1
 
Gary L. Ackerman
D NY-5
 
Thomas H. Allen
D ME-1
 
Robert E. Andrews
D NJ-1
 
Scotty Baesler
D KY-6
 
John Baldacci
D ME-2
 
James A. Barcia
D MI-5
 
Bill Barrett
R NE-3
 
Thomas M. Barrett
D WI-5
 
Charles F. Bass
R NH-2
 
Xavier Becerra
D CA-30
 
Ken Bentsen
D TX-25
 
Howard L. Berman
D CA-26
 
Marion Berry
D AR-1
 
Brian P. Bilbray
R CA-49
 
Sanford D. Bishop Jr.
D GA-2
 
Rod Blagojevich
D IL-5
 
Earl Blumenauer
D OR-3
 
Sherwood L. Boehlert
R NY-23
 
David E. Bonior
D MI-10
 
Robert A. Borski
D PA-3
 
Leonard L. Boswell
D IA-3
 
Rick Boucher
D VA-9
 
Allen Boyd
D FL-2
 
Robert A. Brady
D PA-1
 
Kevin Brady
R TX-8
 
George E. Brown
D CA-42
 
Corrine Brown
D FL-3
 
Sherrod Brown
D OH-13
 
Tom Campbell
R CA-15
 
Walter Capps
D CA-22
 
Benjamin L. Cardin
D MD-3
 
Julia M. Carson
D IN-10
 
Michael N. Castle
R DE-1
 
Steven J. Chabot
R OH-1
 
Helen Chenoweth-Hage
R ID-1
 
William Clay
D MO-1
 
Eva Clayton
D NC-1
 
Bob Clement
D TN-5
 
James E. Clyburn
D SC-6
 
Gary Condit
D CA-18
 
John Conyers Jr.
D MI-14
 
Merrill Cook
R UT-2
 
Jerry F. Costello
D IL-12
 
William J. Coyne
D PA-14
 
Robert E. Cramer
D AL-5
 
Michael D. Crapo
R ID-2
 
Elijah E. Cummings
D MD-7
 
Pat Danner
D MO-6
 
James Davis
D FL-11
 
Danny K. Davis
D IL-7
 
Peter A. DeFazio
D OR-4
 
Diana DeGette
D CO-1
 
Bill Delahunt
D MA-10
 
Rosa DeLauro
D CT-3
 
Peter Deutsch
D FL-20
 
Lincoln Diaz-Balart
R FL-21
 
Norman D. Dicks
D WA-6
 
John D. Dingell
D MI-16
 
Julian C. Dixon
D CA-32
 
Lloyd Doggett
D TX-10
 
Calvin M. Dooley
D CA-20
 
Mike Doyle
D PA-18
 
Chet Edwards
D TX-11
 
Eliot L. Engel
D NY-17
 
Phil English
R PA-21
 
Anna G. Eshoo
D CA-14
 
Bob Etheridge
D NC-2
 
Lane A. Evans
D IL-17
 
Sam Farr
D CA-17
 
Chaka Fattah
D PA-2
 
Vic Fazio
D CA-3
 
Bob Filner
D CA-50
 
Michael P. Forbes
R NY-1
 
Harold E. Ford Jr.
D TN-9
 
Jon D. Fox
R PA-13
 
Barney Frank
D MA-4
 
Bob Franks
R NJ-7
 
Rodney Frelinghuysen
R NJ-11
 
Martin Frost
D TX-24
 
Elizabeth Furse
D OR-1
 
Greg Ganske
R IA-4
 
Sam Gejdenson
D CT-2
 
Richard Andrew Gephardt
D MO-3
 
Wayne T. Gilchrest
R MD-1
 
Paul E. Gillmor
R OH-5
 
Benjamin A. Gilman
R NY-20
 
Virgil H. Goode
D VA-5
 
Bart Gordon
D TN-6
 
Gene Green
D TX-29
 
James C. Greenwood
R PA-8
 
Luis V. Gutiérrez
D IL-4
 
Tony P. Hall
D OH-3
 
Ralph M. Hall
D TX-4
 
Lee H. Hamilton
D IN-9
 
Jane Harman
D CA-36
 
Alcee L. Hastings
D FL-23
 
Bill Hefner
D NC-8
 
Rick Hill
R MT-1
 
Earl F. Hilliard
D AL-7
 
Maurice D. Hinchey
D NY-26
 
Rubén Hinojosa
D TX-15
 
Tim Holden
D PA-6
 
Darlene Hooley
D OR-5
 
Amory Houghton
R NY-31
 
Steny H. Hoyer
D MD-5
 
Asa Hutchinson
R AR-3
 
Jesse L. Jackson Jr.
D IL-2
 
Sheila Jackson-Lee
D TX-18
 
William J. Jefferson
D LA-2
 
Christopher John
D LA-7
 
Nancy Lee Johnson
R CT-6
 
Jay W. Johnson
D WI-8
 
Eddie Bernice Johnson
D TX-30
 
Paul E. Kanjorski
D PA-11
 
Marcy Kaptur
D OH-9
 
Sue W. Kelly
R NY-19
 
Joseph P. Kennedy II
D MA-8
 
Patrick J. Kennedy
D RI-1
 
Barbara B. Kennelly
D CT-1
 
Dale E. Kildee
D MI-9
 
Carolyn Cheeks Kilpatrick
D MI-15
 
Jay Kim
R CA-41
 
Ron Kind
D WI-3
 
Peter T. King
R NY-3
 
Gerald D. Kleczka
D WI-4
 
Ron Klink
D PA-4
 
Scott L. Klug
R WI-2
 
Dennis J. Kucinich
D OH-10
 
John J. LaFalce
D NY-29
 
Nicholas V. Lampson
D TX-9
 
Tom Lantos
D CA-12
 
Steven C. LaTourette
R OH-19
 
Rick Lazio
R NY-2
 
James A. Leach
R IA-1
 
Barbara Lee
D CA-9
 
Sander M. Levin
D MI-12
 
John Lewis
D GA-5
 
Frank A. LoBiondo
R NJ-2
 
Zoe Lofgren
D CA-16
 
Nita M. Lowey
D NY-18
 
Bill Luther
D MN-6
 
James H. Maloney
D CT-5
 
Carolyn B. Maloney
D NY-14
 
Thomas J. Manton
D NY-7
 
Donald Manzullo
R IL-16
 
Edward J. Markey
D MA-7
 
Matthew G. Martinez
D CA-31
 
Frank Mascara
D PA-20
 
Robert T. Matsui
D CA-5
 
Karen McCarthy
D MO-5
 
Carolyn McCarthy
D NY-4
 
Jim McDermott
D WA-7
 
Jim McGovern
D MA-3
 
Paul McHale
D PA-15
 
Mike McIntyre
D NC-7
 
Cynthia McKinney
D GA-11
 
Michael R. McNulty
D NY-21
 
Martin T. Meehan
D MA-5
 
Carrie P. Meek
D FL-17
 
Gregory W. Meeks
D NY-6
 
Robert Menendez
D NJ-13
 
Jack Metcalf
R WA-2
 
Juanita Millender-McDonald
D CA-37
 
George Miller
D CA-7
 
David Minge
D MN-2
 
Patsy T. Mink
D HI-2
 
Alan B. Mollohan
D WV-1
 
James P. Moran
D VA-8
 
Constance A. Morella
R MD-8
 
John P. Murtha
D PA-12
 
Jerrold Nadler
D NY-8
 
Richard E. Neal
D MA-2
 
Anne Meagher Northup
R KY-3
 
James L. Oberstar
D MN-8
 
David R. Obey
D WI-7
 
John W. Olver
D MA-1
 
Solomon P. Ortiz
D TX-27
 
Major R. Owens
D NY-11
 
Frank Pallone
D NJ-6
 
Michael Pappas
R NJ-12
 
Mike Parker
R MS-4
 
Bill Pascrell Jr.
D NJ-8
 
Ed Pastor
D AZ-2
 
Ron Paul
R TX-14
 
Donald M. Payne
D NJ-10
 
Nancy Pelosi
D CA-8
 
Collin C. Peterson
D MN-7
 
Tom Petri
R WI-6
 
Owen B. Pickett
D VA-2
 
Earl Pomeroy
D ND-1
 
John Edward Porter
R IL-10
 
Rob Portman
R OH-2
 
Glenn Poshard
D IL-19
 
David E. Price
D NC-4
 
Jack Quinn
R NY-30
 
Nick J. Rahall II
D WV-3
 
James M. Ramstad
R MN-3
 
Ralph Regula
R OH-16
 
Silvestre Reyes
D TX-16
 
Lynn N. Rivers
D MI-13
 
Ciro D. Rodriguez
D TX-28
 
Tim Roemer
D IN-3
 
Ileana Ros-Lehtinen
R FL-18
 
Steven R. Rothman
D NJ-9
 
Marge Roukema
R NJ-5
 
Lucille Roybal-Allard
D CA-33
 
Bobby L. Rush
D IL-1
 
Martin Olav Sabo
D MN-5
 
Loretta Sánchez
D CA-46
 
Bernard Sanders
ID VT-1
 
Max A. Sandlin
D TX-1
 
Mark Sanford
R SC-1
 
Tom Sawyer
D OH-14
 
H. James Saxton
R NJ-3
 
Bob Schaffer
R CO-4
 
Charles E. Schumer
D NY-9
 
Robert C. Scott
D VA-3
 
José E. Serrano
D NY-16
 
Christopher H. Shays
R CT-4
 
Brad Sherman
D CA-24
 
Norman Sisisky
D VA-4
 
David E. Skaggs
D CO-2
 
Ike Skelton
D MO-4
 
Louise M. Slaughter
D NY-28
 
Christopher H. Smith
R NJ-4
 
Adam Smith
D WA-9
 
Linda Smith
R WA-3
 
Vic Snyder
D AR-2
 
Mark Souder
R IN-4
 
John M. Spratt Jr.
D SC-5
 
Debbie Stabenow
D MI-8
 
Pete Stark
D CA-13
 
Charles W. Stenholm
D TX-17
 
Louis Stokes
D OH-11
 
Ted Strickland
D OH-6
 
Bart Stupak
D MI-1
 
John E. Sununu
R NH-1
 
John Tanner
D TN-8
 
Ellen O. Tauscher
D CA-10
 
Gene Taylor
D MS-5
 
Bennie Thompson
D MS-2
 
Karen L. Thurman
D FL-5
 
John F. Tierney
D MA-6
 
Esteban Edward Torres
D CA-34
 
James Turner
D TX-2
 
Nydia M. Velázquez
D NY-12
 
Bruce F. Vento
D MN-4
 
Peter J. Visclosky
D IN-1
 
James T. Walsh
R NY-25
 
Maxine Waters
D CA-35
 
Melvin Watt
D NC-12
 
Henry A. Waxman
D CA-29
 
Robert Wexler
D FL-19
 
Robert A. Weygand
D RI-2
 
Rick White
R WA-1
 
Robert E. Wise Jr.
D WV-2
 
Lynn Woolsey
D CA-6
 
Albert Russell Wynn
D MD-4
 
Sidney R. Yates
D IL-9

Did Not Vote (9)

Member Party Dist.
 
Newt Gingrich
R GA-6
 
Henry B. Gonzalez
D TX-20
 
Ernest J. Istook
R OK-5
 
John Linder
R GA-4
 
Joseph M. McDade
R PA-10
 
Joe Moakley
D MA-9
 
Charles B. Rangel
D NY-15
 
Frank Riggs
R CA-1
 
Edolphus Towns
D NY-10
 
C. W. Bill Young
R FL-10

* By tradition, the Speaker of the House votes at his or her discretion. In cases where the Speaker does not vote, that absence is not counted in the "Not Voting" totals displayed here, but Represent adds the Speaker's name to the list of people who did not vote.

Close Comment Creative Commons Donate Email Facebook Mobile Phone Podcast Print Google News logo Google_NewsInitiative_Lockup_FullColor RSS Search Search Twitter WhatsApp Resolving differences Check Building Arrow right Info circle Oops OOPS Pencil File text Bars Search Close Cogs Filter Compare Revolving Door Info card Activity Member menu Globe Document External link Quote News Calendar No Vote
Current site Current page