House Vote 420 - On Motion to Recommit with Instructions

Bill:	H.R.4600 - To improve patient access to health care services and provide improved medical care by reducing t...
Description:	Help Efficient, Accessible, Low Cost, Timely Healthcare Act of 2002
Result:	Failed by a margin of 17 votes (simple majority required to pass)
Date:	September 26, 2002 at 3:13 p.m. EDT (vote source)

	R	D	Total
Yes	6	186	193	186 6 1
No	212	13	225	13 212
Other*	5	10	15	10 5

*Includes members who did not vote or voted "present"

Complete Roll Call

Explanation available

Mistaken vote

Yes Votes (193)

Member	Party	Dist.
Neil Abercrombie	D	HI-1
Gary L. Ackerman	D	NY-5
Thomas H. Allen	D	ME-1
Robert E. Andrews	D	NJ-1
Joe Baca	D	CA-42
Brian Baird	D	WA-3
John Baldacci	D	ME-2
Tammy Baldwin	D	WI-2
Thomas M. Barrett	D	WI-5
Xavier Becerra	D	CA-30
Ken Bentsen	D	TX-25
Shelley Berkley	D	NV-1
Howard L. Berman	D	CA-26
Marion Berry	D	AR-1
Sanford D. Bishop Jr.	D	GA-2
Rod Blagojevich	D	IL-5
Earl Blumenauer	D	OR-3
Robert A. Borski	D	PA-3
Leonard L. Boswell	D	IA-3
Rick Boucher	D	VA-9
Robert A. Brady	D	PA-1
Corrine Brown	D	FL-3
Sherrod Brown	D	OH-13
Lois Capps	D	CA-22
Michael E. Capuano	D	MA-8
Benjamin L. Cardin	D	MD-3
Julia M. Carson	D	IN-10
Brad Carson	D	OK-2
William Lacy Clay	D	MO-1
Eva Clayton	D	NC-1
Bob Clement	D	TN-5
James E. Clyburn	D	SC-6
Howard Coble	R	NC-6
Gary Condit	D	CA-18
John Conyers Jr.	D	MI-14
Jerry F. Costello	D	IL-12
William J. Coyne	D	PA-14
Joseph Crowley	D	NY-7
Elijah E. Cummings	D	MD-7
Susan A. Davis	D	CA-49
James Davis	D	FL-11
Danny K. Davis	D	IL-7
Peter A. DeFazio	D	OR-4
Diana DeGette	D	CO-1
Bill Delahunt	D	MA-10
Rosa DeLauro	D	CT-3
Peter Deutsch	D	FL-20
Norman D. Dicks	D	WA-6
John D. Dingell	D	MI-16
Lloyd Doggett	D	TX-10
Calvin M. Dooley	D	CA-20
Mike Doyle	D	PA-18
John J. Duncan Jr.	R	TN-2
Chet Edwards	D	TX-11
Eliot L. Engel	D	NY-17
Phil English	R	PA-21
Anna G. Eshoo	D	CA-14
Bob Etheridge	D	NC-2
Lane A. Evans	D	IL-17
Sam Farr	D	CA-17
Chaka Fattah	D	PA-2
Bob Filner	D	CA-50
Harold E. Ford Jr.	D	TN-9
Barney Frank	D	MA-4
Martin Frost	D	TX-24
Greg Ganske	R	IA-4
Richard Andrew Gephardt	D	MO-3
Charlie Gonzalez	D	TX-20
Bart Gordon	D	TN-6
Lindsey Graham	R	SC-3
Gene Green	D	TX-29
Luis V. Gutiérrez	D	IL-4
Jane Harman	D	CA-36
Alcee L. Hastings	D	FL-23
Baron P. Hill	D	IN-9
Maurice D. Hinchey	D	NY-26
Rubén Hinojosa	D	TX-15
Joseph M. Hoeffel	D	PA-13
Rush Holt	D	NJ-12
Michael M. Honda	D	CA-15
Darlene Hooley	D	OR-5
Steny H. Hoyer	D	MD-5
Jay Inslee	D	WA-1
Jesse L. Jackson Jr.	D	IL-2
Sheila Jackson-Lee	D	TX-18
William J. Jefferson	D	LA-2
Christopher John	D	LA-7
Timothy V. Johnson	R	IL-15
Eddie Bernice Johnson	D	TX-30
Stephanie Tubbs Jones	D	OH-11
Paul E. Kanjorski	D	PA-11
Marcy Kaptur	D	OH-9
Patrick J. Kennedy	D	RI-1
Dale E. Kildee	D	MI-9
Carolyn Cheeks Kilpatrick	D	MI-15
Ron Kind	D	WI-3
Gerald D. Kleczka	D	WI-4
Dennis J. Kucinich	D	OH-10
John J. LaFalce	D	NY-29
Nicholas V. Lampson	D	TX-9
Jim Langevin	D	RI-2
Tom Lantos	D	CA-12
Rick Larsen	D	WA-2
John B. Larson	D	CT-1
Barbara Lee	D	CA-9
Sander M. Levin	D	MI-12
John Lewis	D	GA-5
William O. Lipinski	D	IL-3
Zoe Lofgren	D	CA-16
Nita M. Lowey	D	NY-18
Bill Luther	D	MN-6
Stephen F. Lynch	D	MA-9
James H. Maloney	D	CT-5
Edward J. Markey	D	MA-7
Frank Mascara	D	PA-20
Jim Matheson	D	UT-2
Robert T. Matsui	D	CA-5
Karen McCarthy	D	MO-5
Carolyn McCarthy	D	NY-4
Betty McCollum	D	MN-4
Jim McGovern	D	MA-3
Mike McIntyre	D	NC-7
Michael R. McNulty	D	NY-21
Martin T. Meehan	D	MA-5
Carrie P. Meek	D	FL-17
Gregory W. Meeks	D	NY-6
Robert Menendez	D	NJ-13
Juanita Millender-McDonald	D	CA-37
George Miller	D	CA-7
Alan B. Mollohan	D	WV-1
Dennis Moore	D	KS-3
Jerrold Nadler	D	NY-8
Grace F. Napolitano	D	CA-34
Richard E. Neal	D	MA-2
James L. Oberstar	D	MN-8
David R. Obey	D	WI-7
John W. Olver	D	MA-1
Solomon P. Ortiz	D	TX-27
Major R. Owens	D	NY-11
Frank Pallone	D	NJ-6
Bill Pascrell Jr.	D	NJ-8
Ed Pastor	D	AZ-2
Donald M. Payne	D	NJ-10
Nancy Pelosi	D	CA-8
David D. Phelps	D	IL-19
David E. Price	D	NC-4
Nick J. Rahall II	D	WV-3
Charles B. Rangel	D	NY-15
Silvestre Reyes	D	TX-16
Lynn N. Rivers	D	MI-13
Ciro D. Rodriguez	D	TX-28
Tim Roemer	D	IN-3
Mike Ross	D	AR-4
Steven R. Rothman	D	NJ-9
Lucille Roybal-Allard	D	CA-33
Bobby L. Rush	D	IL-1
Martin Olav Sabo	D	MN-5
Loretta Sánchez	D	CA-46
Bernard Sanders	ID	VT-1
Max A. Sandlin	D	TX-1
Tom Sawyer	D	OH-14
Jan Schakowsky	D	IL-9
Adam B. Schiff	D	CA-27
Robert C. Scott	D	VA-3
José E. Serrano	D	NY-16
Brad Sherman	D	CA-24
Ronnie Shows	D	MS-4
Ike Skelton	D	MO-4
Adam Smith	D	WA-9
Vic Snyder	D	AR-2
Hilda L. Solis	D	CA-31
John M. Spratt Jr.	D	SC-5
Pete Stark	D	CA-13
Ted Strickland	D	OH-6
Bart Stupak	D	MI-1
John Tanner	D	TN-8
Ellen O. Tauscher	D	CA-10
Bennie Thompson	D	MS-2
John F. Tierney	D	MA-6
Edolphus Towns	D	NY-10
James Turner	D	TX-2
Mark Udall	D	CO-2
Tom Udall	D	NM-3
Nydia M. Velázquez	D	NY-12
Maxine Waters	D	CA-35
Diane Watson	D	CA-32
Melvin Watt	D	NC-12
Henry A. Waxman	D	CA-29
Anthony Weiner	D	NY-9
Robert Wexler	D	FL-19
Lynn Woolsey	D	CA-6
David Wu	D	OR-1
Albert Russell Wynn	D	MD-4

No Votes (225)

Member	Party	Dist.
Robert B. Aderholt	R	AL-4
Todd Akin	R	MO-2
Richard K. Armey	R	TX-26
Richard Hugh Baker	R	LA-6
Cass Ballenger	R	NC-10
Bob Barr	R	GA-7
Roscoe G. Bartlett	R	MD-6
Joe L. Barton	R	TX-6
Charles F. Bass	R	NH-2
Douglas K. Bereuter	R	NE-1
Judy Biggert	R	IL-13
Michael Bilirakis	R	FL-9
Roy Blunt	R	MO-7
Sherwood L. Boehlert	R	NY-23
John A. Boehner	R	OH-8
Henry Bonilla	R	TX-23
Mary Bono Mack	R	CA-44
John Boozman	R	AR-3
Allen Boyd	D	FL-2
Kevin Brady	R	TX-8
Henry E. Brown Jr.	R	SC-1
Ed Bryant	R	TN-7
Richard M. Burr	R	NC-5
Dan Burton	R	IN-6
Steve Buyer	R	IN-5
Ken Calvert	R	CA-43
Dave Camp	R	MI-4
Christopher B. Cannon	R	UT-3
Eric Cantor	R	VA-7
Shelley Moore Capito	R	WV-2
Michael N. Castle	R	DE-1
Steven J. Chabot	R	OH-1
Saxby Chambliss	R	GA-8
Michael Allen Collins	R	GA-3
Larry Combest	R	TX-19
John Cooksey	R	LA-5
Christopher Cox	R	CA-47
Robert E. Cramer	D	AL-5
Philip M. Crane	R	IL-8
Ander Crenshaw	R	FL-4
Barbara L. Cubin	R	WY-1
John Culberson	R	TX-7
Randy 'Duke' Cunningham	R	CA-51
Jo Ann S. Davis	R	VA-1
Thomas M. Davis	R	VA-11
Nathan Deal	R	GA-9
Thomas Dale DeLay	R	TX-22
Jim DeMint	R	SC-4
Lincoln Diaz-Balart	R	FL-21
John T. Doolittle	R	CA-4
David Dreier	R	CA-28
Jennifer B. Dunn	R	WA-8
Vernon J. Ehlers	R	MI-3
Robert L. Ehrlich	R	MD-2
Jo Ann Emerson	R	MO-8
Terry Everett	R	AL-2
Michael Ferguson	R	NJ-7
Jeff Flake	R	AZ-1
Ernest Lee Fletcher	R	KY-6
Mark Adam Foley	R	FL-16
J. Randy Forbes	R	VA-4
Vito J. Fossella	R	NY-13
Rodney Frelinghuysen	R	NJ-11
Elton Gallegly	R	CA-23
George W. Gekas	R	PA-17
James A. Gibbons	R	NV-2
Wayne T. Gilchrest	R	MD-1
Paul E. Gillmor	R	OH-5
Benjamin A. Gilman	R	NY-20
Virgil H. Goode	R	VA-5
Robert W. Goodlatte	R	VA-6
Porter J. Goss	R	FL-14
Kay Granger	R	TX-12
Sam Graves	R	MO-6
Mark A. Green	R	WI-8
James C. Greenwood	R	PA-8
Felix J. Grucci Jr.	R	NY-1
Gilbert W. Gutknecht	R	MN-1
Ralph M. Hall	D	TX-4
James V. Hansen	R	UT-1
Melissa A. Hart	R	PA-4
Doc Hastings	R	WA-4
Robin C. Hayes	R	NC-8
John D. Hayworth	R	AZ-6
Joel Hefley	R	CO-5
Wally Herger	R	CA-2
Van Hilleary	R	TN-4
David Lee Hobson	R	OH-7
Peter Hoekstra	R	MI-2
Tim Holden	D	PA-6
Stephen Horn	R	CA-38
John Nathan Hostettler	R	IN-8
Amory Houghton	R	NY-31
Kenny C. Hulshof	R	MO-9
Duncan L. Hunter	R	CA-52
Henry John Hyde	R	IL-6
Johnny Isakson	R	GA-6
Darrell Issa	R	CA-48
Ernest J. Istook	R	OK-5
William Lewis Jenkins	R	TN-1
Nancy Lee Johnson	R	CT-6
Sam Johnson	R	TX-3
Walter B. Jones	R	NC-3
Ric Keller	R	FL-8
Sue W. Kelly	R	NY-19
Mark R. Kennedy	R	MN-2
Brian D. Kerns	R	IN-7
Peter T. King	R	NY-3
Jack Kingston	R	GA-1
Mark Steven Kirk	R	IL-10
Joseph K. Knollenberg	R	MI-11
James T. Kolbe	R	AZ-5
Ray H. LaHood	R	IL-18
Tom Latham	R	IA-5
Steven C. LaTourette	R	OH-19
James A. Leach	R	IA-1
Jerry Lewis	R	CA-40
Ron Lewis	R	KY-2
John Linder	R	GA-11
Frank A. LoBiondo	R	NJ-2
Kenneth R. Lucas	D	KY-4
Frank D. Lucas	R	OK-6
Donald Manzullo	R	IL-16
Jim O. McCrery	R	LA-4
John M. McHugh	R	NY-24
Scott McInnis	R	CO-3
Howard P. McKeon	R	CA-25
Cynthia McKinney	D	GA-4
John L. Mica	R	FL-7
Dan Miller	R	FL-13
Gary G. Miller	R	CA-41
Jeff Miller	R	FL-1
Jerry Moran	R	KS-1
James P. Moran	D	VA-8
Constance A. Morella	R	MD-8
John P. Murtha	D	PA-12
Sue Myrick	R	NC-9
George R. Nethercutt	R	WA-5
Robert William Ney	R	OH-18
Anne Meagher Northup	R	KY-3
Charles W. Norwood	R	GA-10
James Allen Nussle	R	IA-2
Thomas William Osborne	R	NE-3
Doug Ose	R	CA-3
C.L. Otter	R	ID-1
Michael G. Oxley	R	OH-4
Ron Paul	R	TX-14
Mike Pence	R	IN-2
Collin C. Peterson	D	MN-7
John E. Peterson	R	PA-5
Tom Petri	R	WI-6
Charles W. Pickering	R	MS-3
Joe Pitts	R	PA-16
Todd R. Platts	R	PA-19
Richard W. Pombo	R	CA-11
Earl Pomeroy	D	ND-1
Rob Portman	R	OH-2
Deborah D. Pryce	R	OH-15
Adam H. Putnam	R	FL-12
Jack Quinn	R	NY-30
George P. Radanovich	R	CA-19
James M. Ramstad	R	MN-3
Ralph Regula	R	OH-16
Denny Rehberg	R	MT-1
Thomas M. Reynolds	R	NY-27
Bob Riley	R	AL-3
Harold Rogers	R	KY-5
Mike Rogers	R	MI-8
Dana Rohrabacher	R	CA-45
Ileana Ros-Lehtinen	R	FL-18
Ed Royce	R	CA-39
Paul D. Ryan *	R	WI-1
Jim R. Ryun	R	KS-2
H. James Saxton	R	NJ-3
Bob Schaffer	R	CO-4
Edward L. Schrock	R	VA-2
F. James Sensenbrenner	R	WI-9
Pete Sessions	R	TX-5
John Shadegg	R	AZ-4
E. Clay Shaw	R	FL-22
Christopher H. Shays	R	CT-4
Donald L. Sherwood	R	PA-10
John Shimkus	R	IL-20
Bud Shuster	R	PA-9
Robert Ruhl Simmons	R	CT-2
Mike Simpson	R	ID-2
Joe Skeen	R	NM-2
Nick Smith	R	MI-7
Christopher H. Smith	R	NJ-4
Lamar Smith	R	TX-21
Mark Souder	R	IN-4
Cliff Stearns	R	FL-6
Charles W. Stenholm	D	TX-17
John Sullivan	R	OK-1
John E. Sununu	R	NH-1
John E. Sweeney	R	NY-22
Thomas G. Tancredo	R	CO-6
William J. Tauzin	R	LA-3
Gene Taylor	D	MS-5
Charles H. Taylor	R	NC-11
Lee Terry	R	NE-2
William M. Thomas	R	CA-21
William M. Thornberry	R	TX-13
John Thune	R	SD-1
Todd Tiahrt	R	KS-4
Pat Tiberi	R	OH-12
Patrick J. Toomey	R	PA-15
Fred Upton	R	MI-6
Peter J. Visclosky	D	IN-1
David Vitter	R	LA-1
Greg Walden	R	OR-2
James T. Walsh	R	NY-25
Zach Wamp	R	TN-3
Wes Watkins	R	OK-3
J.C. Watts	R	OK-4
David J. Weldon	R	FL-15
W. Curtis Weldon	R	PA-7
Gerald C. Weller	R	IL-11
Edward Whitfield	R	KY-1
Roger Wicker	R	MS-1
Heather A. Wilson	R	NM-1
Joe Wilson	R	SC-2
Frank R. Wolf	R	VA-10
Don Young	R	AK-1
C. W. Bill Young	R	FL-10

Did Not Vote (14)

Member	Party	Dist.
Spencer Bachus	R	AL-6
James A. Barcia	D	MI-5
David E. Bonior	D	MI-10
Sonny Callahan	R	AL-1
J. Dennis Hastert	R	IL-14
Earl F. Hilliard	D	AL-7
Steve Israel	D	NY-2
Carolyn B. Maloney	D	NY-14
Jim McDermott	D	WA-7
Patsy T. Mink	D	HI-2
Marge Roukema	R	NJ-5
Louise M. Slaughter	D	NY-28
Bob Stump	R	AZ-3
Mike Thompson	D	CA-1
Karen L. Thurman	D	FL-5

* By tradition, the Speaker of the House votes at his or her discretion. In cases where the Speaker does not vote, that absence is not counted in the "Not Voting" totals displayed here, but Represent adds the Speaker's name to the list of people who did not vote.

Legislators

Bills

Statements

Lobbying

Travel

Yes Votes (193)

No Votes (225)

Did Not Vote (14)