Senate Vote 348 - On the Amendment

Description: Nickles Amendment No. 2175; To use a 5-year average rather than a 10-year average in computing the average account benefits ratio.
Result: Rejected by a margin of 23 votes (simple majority required to pass)
Date: ()
R D I Total
Yes 27 
27
27
 
No 21 
50 
72
50
21
1
 
Other*
1
1
 
*Includes members who did not vote or voted "present"

Complete Roll Call

Explanation available
Mistaken vote

Yes Votes (27)

Member Party State
 
Wayne A. Allard
R CO
 
Robert F. Bennett
R UT
 
Christopher S. Bond
R MO
 
Jim Bunning
R KY
 
Conrad Burns
R MT
 
Ben Nighthorse Campbell
R CO
 
Thad Cochran
R MS
 
John Ensign
R NV
 
Peter G. Fitzgerald
R IL
 
William H. Frist
R TN
 
Phil Gramm
R TX
 
Charles E. Grassley
R IA
 
Judd Gregg
R NH
 
Jesse Helms
R NC
 
Jon Kyl
R AZ
 
Trent Lott
R MS
 
Richard G. Lugar
R IN
 
John McCain
R AZ
 
Mitch McConnell
R KY
 
Don Nickles
R OK
 
Richard J. Santorum
R PA
 
Jeff Sessions
R AL
 
Bob Smith
R NH
 
Craig Thomas
R WY
 
Fred Thompson
R TN
 
Strom Thurmond
R SC
 
George V. Voinovich
R OH

No Votes (72)

Member Party State
 
Daniel K. Akaka
D HI
 
George Felix Allen
R VA
 
Max Baucus
D MT
 
Evan Bayh
D IN
 
Joseph R. Biden Jr.
D DE
 
Jeff Bingaman
D NM
 
Barbara Boxer
D CA
 
John B. Breaux
D LA
 
Sam Brownback
R KS
 
Robert C. Byrd
D WV
 
Maria Cantwell
D WA
 
Jean Carnahan
D MO
 
Thomas R. Carper
D DE
 
Lincoln D. Chafee
R RI
 
Max Cleland
D GA
 
Hillary Rodham Clinton
D NY
 
Susan Collins
R ME
 
Kent Conrad
D ND
 
Jon Stevens Corzine
D NJ
 
Larry E. Craig
R ID
 
Michael D. Crapo
R ID
 
Thomas A. Daschle
D SD
 
Mark Dayton
D MN
 
Michael DeWine
R OH
 
Christopher J. Dodd
D CT
 
Pete V. Domenici
R NM
 
Byron L. Dorgan
D ND
 
Richard J. Durbin
D IL
 
John Reid Edwards
D NC
 
Michael B. Enzi
R WY
 
Russ Feingold
D WI
 
Dianne Feinstein
D CA
 
Bob Graham
D FL
 
Chuck T. Hagel
R NE
 
Tom Harkin
D IA
 
Orrin G. Hatch
R UT
 
Ernest F. Hollings
D SC
 
Tim Hutchinson
R AR
 
James M. Inhofe
R OK
 
Daniel K. Inouye
D HI
 
James M. Jeffords
ID VT
 
Tim Johnson
D SD
 
Edward M. Kennedy
D MA
 
John Kerry
D MA
 
Herb Kohl
D WI
 
Mary L. Landrieu
D LA
 
Patrick J. Leahy
D VT
 
Carl Levin
D MI
 
Joseph I. Lieberman
D CT
 
Blanche Lincoln
D AR
 
Barbara A. Mikulski
D MD
 
Zell Bryan Miller
D GA
 
Frank H. Murkowski
R AK
 
Patty Murray
D WA
 
Bill Nelson
D FL
 
Ben Nelson
D NE
 
Jack Reed
D RI
 
Harry Reid
D NV
 
Pat Roberts
R KS
 
John D. Rockefeller IV
D WV
 
Paul S. Sarbanes
D MD
 
Charles E. Schumer
D NY
 
Richard C. Shelby
R AL
 
Gordon Harold Smith
R OR
 
Olympia J. Snowe
R ME
 
Arlen Specter
R PA
 
Debbie Stabenow
D MI
 
Ted F. Stevens
R AK
 
Robert G. Torricelli
D NJ
 
John W. Warner
R VA
 
Paul D. Wellstone
D MN
 
Ron Wyden
D OR

Did Not Vote (1)

Member Party State
 
Kay Bailey Hutchison
R TX
Close Comment Creative Commons Donate Email Facebook Mobile Phone Podcast Print Google News logo Google_NewsInitiative_Lockup_FullColor RSS Search Search Twitter WhatsApp Resolving differences Check Building Arrow right Info circle Oops OOPS Pencil File text Bars Search Close Cogs Filter Compare Revolving Door Info card Activity Member menu Globe Document External link Quote News Calendar No Vote
Current site Current page