ProPublica

Journalism in the Public Interest

Is Your State Providing Equal Access to Education?

This database was last updated in January 2013 and should only be used as a historical snapshot of data from the 2009-10 school year. For more recent data on public and charter schools, check out Miseducation.

ProPublica analyzed federal education data from the 2009-2010 school year to examine whether states provide high-poverty schools equal access to advanced courses and special programs that researchers say will help them later in life. This is the first nationwide picture of exactly which courses are being taken at which schools and districts across the country. More than three-quarters of all public school children are represented. Read our story and our methodology.

Find a school

Clifford H. Smart Middle School

8500 COMMERCE ROAD, COMMERCE TOWNSHIP, MICH., 48382 | Grades 6-8

Districts with 3,000 or more students
Students Total Teachers Inexp. Teachers
This School
945
54
0%
District 15.3K 858 4%
State 949K 49,657 5%
 
State Average
 
District Average

Percentage of relevant students who...

Get Free/Reduced Price Lunch

38%
16%

13%

Are in a Gifted/Talented Program

12%
14%

16%

Are

0%
0%

1% Am Indian
3%
6%

3% Asian
22%
8%

3% Black
5%
2%

1% Hispanic
68%
83%

93% White

Clifford H. Smart Middle School, part of the Walled Lake Consolidated Schools district, is located in Commerce Township, Michigan. The school reports an enrollment number of 945 students in grades six through eight, and it has 54 teachers on staff.

Clifford H. Smart Middle School is below both the state and district averages for the percentage of its students who qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. On average, 38 percent of students in Michigan qualify for free or reduced-price lunches, whereas 13 percent of students at Clifford H. Smart Middle School are eligible. At the district level, 16 percent are eligible.

ProPublica's analysis found that all too often, states and schools provide poor students fewer educational programs like Advanced Placement, gifted and talented programs, and advanced math and science classes. Studies have linked participation in these programs with better outcomes later in life. Our analysis uses free and reduced-price lunch to estimate poverty at schools. We based our findings on the most comprehensive data set of access to advanced classes and special programs in U.S. public schools — known as the Civil Rights Data Set— released by the U.S. Department of Education Office for Civil Rights.

Clifford H. Smart Middle School's enrollment rate for gifted and talented is 16 percent.

Gerald R. Ford Middle School, in Grand Rapids, Mich., is a higher-poverty school than Clifford H. Smart Middle School, with 97 percent of its students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch. The school hasn't reported or may not have a gifted and talented program.

These data points were reported by schools and districts to the Office for Civil Rights. For more information about the data, see our full methodology.

— Generated by Narrative Science