New York State Subsidy Tracker - Livingston County

ProPublica

New York State Subsidy Tracker

Tracking the State’s Growing Portfolio of Business Subsidies

Livingston County

Businesses received $10.3M in subsidies.

Businesses in Livingston County received at least $10.3M in subsidies between 2011 and 2014 from state and local governments.

Note: For cases in which the time period is marked “total,” the subsidy value is the total lifetime amount the company will receive for the project. For all other subsidies, the amount listed is the total for that year.

For subsidies that require annual reports, companies promise to create a total number of jobs over the course of the subsidy, which may last many years. Each year, companies report how many jobs they've created cumulatively as of that year. Therefore, not all jobs figures can be combined.

All Subsidies

Year Time Period Type Company Program Jobs Promised Initially Jobs Reported To Date Value
2011 Annual Tax Exemption AMERICAN ROCK SALT COMPANY LLC Industrial Development Agencies 145 -19 $2.8M
2013 Total Tax Credit GRAY METAL PRODUCTS INC Excelsior Jobs Program 80 0 $900.0K
2014 Annual Tax Exemption AMERICAN ROCK SALT COMPANY LLC Industrial Development Agencies 146 331 $621.9K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption AMERICAN ROCK SALT COMPANY LLC Industrial Development Agencies 146 268 $606.0K
2013 Annual Tax Exemption AMERICAN ROCK SALT COMPANY LLC Industrial Development Agencies 146 280 $594.3K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption AMERICAN ROCK SALT COMPANY LLC Industrial Development Agencies 146 216 $586.9K
2014 Total Power Discount KRAFT FOODS New York Power Authority 394 $427.1K
2014 Total Power Discount AMERICAN ROCK SALT COMPANY LLC New York Power Authority $351.6K
2012 Total Grant ONCE AGAIN NUT BUTTER COLLECTIVE INC Regional Economic Development Councils 53 $300.0K
2011 Total Grant ABVI GOODWILL INC Local Development Corporations 24 22 $263.7K
2013 Annual Tax Exemption COAST PROFESSIONAL INC Industrial Development Agencies 47 46 $223.3K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption MART INN INC Industrial Development Agencies 30 16 $166.6K
2014 Annual Tax Exemption WNY ENTERPRISE LLC Industrial Development Agencies 10 9 $140.0K
2014 Annual Tax Exemption GRAY METAL PRODUCTS INC Industrial Development Agencies 15 18 $138.7K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption GRAY METAL PRODUCTS INC Industrial Development Agencies 10 55 $126.0K
2014 Total Grant OPEN SPACE INSTITUTE Regional Economic Development Councils $100.0K
2013 Total Grant INTEGRATED MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES INC Economic Development Fund 18 $100.0K
2014 Total Tax Credit PPI CORP Excelsior Jobs Program 6 8 $100.0K
2014 Annual Tax Exemption MART INN INC Industrial Development Agencies 30 9 $90.7K
2013 Annual Tax Exemption MART INN INC Industrial Development Agencies 30 14 $89.3K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption SWEETENERS PLUS INC Industrial Development Agencies 8 12 $74.9K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption SWEETENERS PLUS INC Industrial Development Agencies 8 16 $74.6K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption SUPERIOR FOUNDATIONS OF NY INC Industrial Development Agencies 17 -50 $70.5K
2014 Total Grant PALACE PROPERTIES OF GENESEO INC Local Development Corporations $65.7K
2013 Annual Tax Exemption SWEETENERS PLUS INC Industrial Development Agencies 8 20 $64.3K
2014 Total Power Discount AMERICAN ROCK SALT COMPANY LLC New York Power Authority 283 $62.5K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption MART INN INC Industrial Development Agencies 30 36 $62.1K
2013 Annual Tax Exemption SUPERIOR FOUNDATIONS OF NY INC Industrial Development Agencies 17 6 $52.5K
2014 Annual Tax Exemption SWEETENERS PLUS INC Industrial Development Agencies 8 7 $49.8K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption COAST PROFESSIONAL INC Industrial Development Agencies 50 80 $49.6K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption MATTICE BROTHERS PROPERTIES LLC Industrial Development Agencies 5 7 $47.3K
2014 Annual Tax Exemption SUPERIOR FOUNDATIONS OF NY INC Industrial Development Agencies 17 14 $44.8K
2014 Annual Tax Exemption CONHOCTON VALLEY RAILROAD CORP Industrial Development Agencies 0 4 $43.2K
2013 Annual Tax Exemption WNY ENTERPRISE LLC Industrial Development Agencies 10 0 $41.9K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption CONHOCTON VALLEY RAILROAD CORP Industrial Development Agencies 0 0 $36.2K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption CONHOCTON VALLEY RAILROAD CORP Industrial Development Agencies 0 4 $32.2K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption COMMODITY RESOURCE CORP Industrial Development Agencies 14 0 $30.4K
2014 Annual Tax Exemption AMERICAN ROCK SALT COMPANY LLC Industrial Development Agencies 0 -350 $30.0K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption MILL CREEK LLC Industrial Development Agencies 10 6 $29.6K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption MONTGOMERY MAXIMUS LLC Industrial Development Agencies 22 5 $26.5K
2014 Total Grant LIVINGSTON COUNTY DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION Regional Economic Development Councils $25.0K
2013 Annual Tax Exemption CONHOCTON VALLEY RAILROAD CORP Industrial Development Agencies 0 4 $24.6K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption GRAY METAL PRODUCTS INC Industrial Development Agencies 10 34 $24.2K
2014 Annual Tax Exemption VALLEY ENERGY SERVICES LLC Industrial Development Agencies 6 4 $23.9K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption COMMODITY RESOURCE CORP Industrial Development Agencies 14 25 $23.4K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption MONTGOMERY MAXIMUS LLC Industrial Development Agencies 22 5 $22.9K
2014 Annual Tax Exemption 1370 ROCHESTER STREET LLC Industrial Development Agencies 20 16 $22.2K
2013 Annual Tax Exemption MONTGOMERY MAXIMUS LLC Industrial Development Agencies 22 2 $21.1K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption 1370 ROCHESTER STREET LLC Industrial Development Agencies 20 8 $20.4K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption BARILLA AMERICA NY INC Industrial Development Agencies 117 123 $20.2K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption SUPERIOR FOUNDATIONS OF NY INC Industrial Development Agencies 17 7 $17.9K
2013 Annual Tax Exemption 1370 ROCHESTER STREET LLC Industrial Development Agencies 20 8 $17.1K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption LIVINGSTON ASSOCIATES INC Industrial Development Agencies 9 -7 $16.9K
2014 Annual Tax Exemption MONTGOMERY MAXIMUS LLC Industrial Development Agencies 22 0 $16.8K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption BARILLA AMERICA NY INC Industrial Development Agencies 117 120 $15.8K
2014 Total Power Discount APPLIED ENERGY SOLUTIONS LLC New York Power Authority 40 $12.2K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption 1370 ROCHESTER STREET LLC Industrial Development Agencies 20 -57 $12.0K
2014 Total Power Discount PPI CORP New York Power Authority 47 $11.9K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption PHYSICAL THERAPY PROFESSIONALS Industrial Development Agencies 4 7 $11.8K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption STAR LAND & DEVELOPMENT COMPANY LLC Industrial Development Agencies 50 60 $10.8K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption PHYSICAL THERAPY PROFESSIONALS Industrial Development Agencies 4 8 $8.8K
2014 Total Power Discount D B WEBB INC New York Power Authority 9 $7.6K
2014 Total Power Discount D B WEBB INC New York Power Authority $7.6K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption LIVINGSTON ASSOCIATES INC Industrial Development Agencies 9 0 $7.5K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption GAC REALTY CORP Industrial Development Agencies 10 35 $5.9K
2011 Total Grant JENNIFER TOMASCHOW Local Development Corporations $5.8K
2011 Total Grant RICHARD GAREY Local Development Corporations $5.8K
2011 Total Grant JENNIFER TOMASCHOW Local Development Corporations $5.8K
2011 Total Grant BARBARA BALDWIN Local Development Corporations $5.8K
2013 Annual Tax Exemption BARILLA AMERICA NY INC Industrial Development Agencies 117 133 $5.5K
2011 Total Grant JON LADELFA Local Development Corporations $5.2K
2013 Annual Tax Exemption PHYSICAL THERAPY PROFESSIONALS Industrial Development Agencies 4 9 $5.0K
2013 Total Grant BALDWIN FAMILY ENT Local Development Corporations $5.0K
2013 Total Grant MARK SCOVILLE Local Development Corporations $5.0K
2011 Total Grant BRIAN TEACHOUT Local Development Corporations $5.0K
2012 Total Grant BRIAN TEACHOUT Local Development Corporations $5.0K
2014 Total Grant GREG O'CONNELL Local Development Corporations $5.0K
2014 Total Grant RUTH COYLE Local Development Corporations $5.0K
2013 Total Grant 118 MAIN STREET GENESEO LLC Local Development Corporations $5.0K
2013 Total Grant VILLAGE CLIPPER Local Development Corporations $5.0K
2013 Total Grant LORRI WELCH Local Development Corporations $5.0K
2013 Total Grant 114 MAIN STREET GENESEO LLC Local Development Corporations $5.0K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption COVERED WAGON TOURS LLC Industrial Development Agencies 8 0 $5.0K
2013 Total Grant RICHARD MARTIN Local Development Corporations $5.0K
2012 Total Grant WILLIAM WADSWORTH Local Development Corporations $5.0K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption MATTICE BROTHERS PROPERTIES LLC Industrial Development Agencies 5 0 $5.0K
2013 Total Grant BALDWIN FAMILY ENT Local Development Corporations $5.0K
2012 Total Grant FRANK GULLO Local Development Corporations $5.0K
2013 Total Grant O'CONNELL ORGANIZATION NORTH LLC Local Development Corporations $5.0K
2012 Total Grant KEVIN READEL Local Development Corporations $4.9K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption COAST PROFESSIONAL INC Industrial Development Agencies 50 113 $4.8K
2013 Total Grant O'CONNELL ORGANIZATION NORTH LLC Local Development Corporations $4.8K
2013 Total Grant LIVONIA INN Local Development Corporations $4.8K
2013 Total Grant VALERIE SINGLETON Local Development Corporations $4.7K
2011 Total Grant ROBERT LAUX Local Development Corporations $4.6K
2014 Total Grant BARBARA BALDWIN Local Development Corporations $4.6K
2013 Total Grant THOMAS PROVO Local Development Corporations $4.3K
2014 Total Grant RICHARD MARTIN Local Development Corporations $4.0K
2011 Total Grant DON BROWN Local Development Corporations $4.0K
2014 Total Grant ED DUTRA Local Development Corporations $4.0K
2014 Total Grant VALERIE SINGLETON Local Development Corporations $4.0K
2013 Total Grant FIX DANSVILLE INC Local Development Corporations $3.9K
2011 Total Grant MARCIA PODHORECKI Local Development Corporations $3.9K
2012 Total Grant GREG O'CONNELL Local Development Corporations $3.8K
2014 Total Grant MARLEEN MARK Local Development Corporations $3.8K
2011 Annual Tax Exemption BULK PRODUCTS DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION Industrial Development Agencies 1 5 $3.5K
2014 Total Grant TOM PROPERTIES Local Development Corporations $3.5K
2011 Total Grant WILMA WILEY Local Development Corporations $3.5K
2012 Total Grant GREG O'CONNELL Local Development Corporations $3.4K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption BULK PRODUCTS DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION Industrial Development Agencies 1 4 $3.2K
2013 Total Grant ONCE AGAIN NUT BUTTER Local Development Corporations $3.2K
2013 Total Grant CONNIE RYAN Local Development Corporations $3.1K
2011 Total Grant SUSAN DEMUTH Local Development Corporations $3.1K
2014 Total Grant MARCIA PODHORECKI Local Development Corporations $3.0K
2013 Total Grant ROBERT WELCH Local Development Corporations $2.9K
2014 Total Grant NORAS PROPERTIES Local Development Corporations $2.9K
2013 Total Grant JIMMY STAKOS Local Development Corporations $2.9K
2014 Total Grant ELAINE FLAHERTY Local Development Corporations $2.7K
2014 Total Grant PAUL SMITH Local Development Corporations $2.4K
2013 Total Grant WILMA WILEY Local Development Corporations $2.4K
2014 Total Grant DOUG HART Local Development Corporations $2.3K
2013 Total Grant EENJ INC Local Development Corporations $2.2K
2012 Total Grant GREG O'CONNELL Local Development Corporations $2.2K
2011 Total Grant THOMAS WAMP Local Development Corporations $2.1K
2014 Total Grant THOMAS PROVO Local Development Corporations $2.1K
2014 Total Grant RALPH PARKER Local Development Corporations $2.0K
2011 Total Grant SUSAN DEMUTH Local Development Corporations $1.9K
2014 Total Grant JEFF SWIFT Local Development Corporations $1.9K
2013 Total Grant DON BROWN Local Development Corporations $1.8K
2014 Total Grant DON BROWN Local Development Corporations $1.8K
2014 Annual Tax Exemption COVERED WAGON TOURS LLC Industrial Development Agencies 8 58 $1.7K
2013 Total Grant CYNTHIA RAU Local Development Corporations $1.7K
2013 Total Grant NICK MACALUSO Local Development Corporations $1.6K
2014 Annual Tax Exemption BULK PRODUCTS DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION Industrial Development Agencies 1 5 $1.6K
2013 Annual Tax Exemption COVERED WAGON TOURS LLC Industrial Development Agencies 8 55 $1.5K
2012 Total Grant DON SYLOR Local Development Corporations $1.5K
2014 Total Grant EDWARD COYNE Local Development Corporations $1.5K
2011 Total Grant JACKIE MORGAN Local Development Corporations $1.4K
2011 Total Grant JACKIE MORGAN Local Development Corporations $1.4K
2013 Annual Tax Exemption COMMODITY RESOURCE CORP Industrial Development Agencies 14 -1 $1.3K
2012 Total Grant PAUL SMITH Local Development Corporations $1.3K
2014 Annual Tax Exemption PHYSICAL THERAPY PROFESSIONALS Industrial Development Agencies 4 4 $1.3K
2013 Annual Tax Exemption BULK PRODUCTS DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION Industrial Development Agencies 1 4 $1.2K
2014 Annual Tax Exemption FOX & WEST INC Industrial Development Agencies 6 0 $1.2K
2012 Total Grant UNION LODGE Local Development Corporations $1.1K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption COVERED WAGON TOURS LLC Industrial Development Agencies 8 55 $1.0K
2011 Total Grant EDGAR SCHMIDT Local Development Corporations $1.0K
2014 Total Grant RUDY HETTIS Local Development Corporations $983.00
2012 Total Grant JIM SULLIVAN Local Development Corporations $919.00
2012 Total Grant DON BROWN Local Development Corporations $840.00
2011 Total Grant DAN HOWELS Local Development Corporations $750.00
2011 Total Grant KRISTIN SWANSON Local Development Corporations $750.00
2014 Total Grant ARC OF LIVINGSTON-WYOMING Local Development Corporations $675.00
2011 Total Grant DENNIS LAKIS Local Development Corporations $575.00
2012 Total Grant JENNIFER HOWARD Local Development Corporations $532.50
2014 Total Grant ELIZABETH DAVIS Local Development Corporations $524.00
2013 Total Grant JILL KALMAR Local Development Corporations $500.00
2013 Total Grant TIMOTHY KNOWLES Local Development Corporations $500.00
2014 Total Grant ARC OF LIVINGSTON-WYOMING Local Development Corporations $483.80
2013 Total Grant PETER SKIVINGTON Local Development Corporations $482.10
2013 Total Grant TIM COLLINS Local Development Corporations $457.50
2011 Annual Tax Exemption LIVINGSTON ASSOCIATES INC Industrial Development Agencies 10 21 $455.60
2012 Total Grant DAN WENSEL Local Development Corporations $391.50
2013 Total Grant RUTH ANN LEWIS Local Development Corporations $284.50
2014 Annual Tax Exemption MATTICE BROTHERS PROPERTIES LLC Industrial Development Agencies 5 0 $199.90
2013 Annual Tax Exemption MATTICE BROTHERS PROPERTIES LLC Industrial Development Agencies 5 5 $174.70
2014 Annual Tax Exemption COAST PROFESSIONAL INC Industrial Development Agencies 50 0 $0
2011 Annual Tax Exemption BULK PRODUCTS DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION Industrial Development Agencies 1 -8 $0
2014 Annual Tax Exemption LIVINGSTON ASSOCIATES INC Industrial Development Agencies 9 -1 $0
2013 Annual Tax Exemption LIVINGSTON ASSOCIATES INC Industrial Development Agencies 9 -3 $0
2013 Annual Tax Exemption GRAY METAL PRODUCTS INC Industrial Development Agencies 10 -125 $0
2014 Annual Tax Exemption DANSVILLE PROPERTIES Industrial Development Agencies 291 15 $0
2014 Annual Tax Exemption BARILLA AMERICA NY INC Industrial Development Agencies 117 131 $0
2013 Annual Tax Exemption MATTICE BROTHERS PROPERTIES LLC Industrial Development Agencies 5 5 $0
2013 Annual Tax Exemption DANSVILLE PROPERTIES Industrial Development Agencies 291 3 $0
2011 Annual Tax Exemption DANSVILLE PROPERTIES Industrial Development Agencies 291 16 $0
2014 Annual Tax Exemption COMMODITY RESOURCE CORP Industrial Development Agencies 14 31 $0
2014 Annual Tax Exemption COAST PROFESSIONAL INC Industrial Development Agencies 47 68 $0
2013 Annual Tax Exemption COAST PROFESSIONAL INC Industrial Development Agencies 50 0 $0
2013 Annual Tax Exemption GRAY METAL PRODUCTS INC Industrial Development Agencies 15 13 $0
2012 Annual Tax Exemption DANSVILLE PROPERTIES Industrial Development Agencies 291 14 -$1.9K
2012 Annual Tax Exemption MILL CREEK LLC Industrial Development Agencies 10 5 -$80.7K

Total Subsidy Value, by Program

Program Total Value (Minimum)
Industrial Development Agencies $7.3M
Excelsior Jobs Program $1.0M
New York Power Authority $880.6K
Local Development Corporations $578.0K
Regional Economic Development Councils $425.0K
Economic Development Fund $100.0K
Western New York Power Proceeds Allocation Board $0
JOBS Now $0
New York Film Tax Credit $0
Start-Up NY $0
Brownfield Cleanup Program $0

Source: Data on subsidies from the Excelsior Jobs Program, Industrial Development Agencies and Local Development Corporations are sourced from New York’s open data portal. IDA data accessed on July 21, 2016. LDC data accessed on Feb. 21, 2017. All other program data sourced from agency reports and Freedom of Information requests to Empire State Development, the state’s economic development arm, and other state agencies. Download the raw program data in the ProPublica Data Store.

Methodology: Read our methodology for collecting the data.

Notes:

Except where otherwise noted, data is for subsidies granted or given out between 2011 and 2014 under the above-named programs. While these programs comprise a significant cross-section of the state’s growing portfolio of economic development programs, they don’t include every subsidy dollar.

Subsidies tracked include grants, tax breaks, low-cost leases and discounted power allocations given out under each program; loans and bond issues are excluded from the data because they have to be repaid.

The number of corporate subsidiaries reflects only the subsidiaries we were able to verify though our research. Companies may have more connections with other companies not listed in the data.

IDA and LDC subsidies are given out by local entities; all other programs are administered by New York State.