ProPublica

Journalism in the Public Interest

Treatment Tracker

How This Provider Compares

This Provider

Avg in State & Specialty

Providers in this state and specialty were reimbursed, on average, $292 per patient in 2014.
They performed about 4 services per patient. Here’s how this provider compares.
Number of
Patients
527
Rank: 185th
out of 333 providers in this state & specialty
Services
Performed
2,874
Rank: 112th
out of 333 providers in this state & specialty
Avg Services
Per Patient
5.5 This Provider
Avg 3.8
Total Paid
by Medicare
$313K
Rank: 45th
out of 333 providers in this state & specialty
Avg Paid
Per Patient
$594 This Provider is in the top 10%
Avg $292

How This Provider’s Patients Compare

Doctors often say their patients are sicker or more complex than those of their peers. The measure displayed below, used by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, takes into account patients’ characteristics to estimate whether they are expected to have above-average Medicare spending. It considers patients’ age, sex, diagnoses from the past year and other factors. This provider’s score below takes into account all of his Part B patients.

Who Patients See Before and After This Provider

Providers often refer their patients to a small network of other providers and organizations. Here’s who patients saw the most patients within 30 days before or after this provider in 2014.

Individuals

NARESH UPADHYAY

RICHARD BAUER

ARI MINTZ

VINCENT ROWLEY

HOWARD KIM

Organizations

ADVOCATE HEALTH AND HOS...

CITY OF CHICAGO

Patients saw before

MANZOOR SHAH MD

Patients saw after

Individuals

NARESH UPADHYAY

AMIT VYAS

ARI MINTZ

RICHARD BAUER

VINCENT ROWLEY

Organizations

ADVOCATE HEALTH AND HOS...

SUPERIOR AIR-GROUND AMB...

This Provider's Services

This provider performed 18 different services in 2014
All Services

Show Only:

Drug Services
Medical Services
CATEGORY
Description of Service
Times Performed (or Units) This Service's Rank Patients Unique Visits
Per Patient
Billed to Medicare Payments from Medicare
medical
EVALUATION AND MANAGEMENT

Subsequent hospital inpatient care, typically 35 minutes ... +

Subsequent hospital inpatient care, typically 35 minutes per day ×

Service Code: 99233
Performed in a facility
1,055
times performed,
37% of his services

1st 2nd

most performed service for this provider most performed service in this state & specialty

265
patients got this service, 50% of his patients
4
average number of visits a patient made for this service
(Peers: 2.6)
$426,800an average of $405 per time performed $87,607
an average of $83 per time performed
medical
EVALUATION AND MANAGEMENT

Established patient office or other outpatient, visit typ... +

Established patient office or other outpatient, visit typically 25 minutes ×

Service Code: 99214
Performed in an office
711
times performed,
25% of his services

2nd 3rd

most performed service for this provider most performed service in this state & specialty

168
patients got this service, 32% of his patients
4.2
average number of visits a patient made for this service
(Peers: 1.7)
$179,997an average of $253 per time performed $55,906
an average of $79 per time performed
medical
EVALUATION AND MANAGEMENT

Critical care delivery critically ill or injured patient,... +

Critical care delivery critically ill or injured patient, first 30-74 minutes ×

Service Code: 99291
Performed in a facility
486
times performed,
17% of his services

3rd 4th

most performed service for this provider most performed service in this state & specialty

137
patients got this service, 26% of his patients
3.5
average number of visits a patient made for this service
(Peers: 2.2)
$272,102an average of $560 per time performed $90,425
an average of $186 per time performed
medical
EVALUATION AND MANAGEMENT

Initial hospital inpatient care, typically 70 minutes per... +

Initial hospital inpatient care, typically 70 minutes per day ×

Service Code: 99223
Performed in a facility
408
times performed,
14% of his services

4th 6th

most performed service for this provider most performed service in this state & specialty

318
patients got this service, 60% of his patients
1.3
average number of visits a patient made for this service
(Peers: 1.1)
$205,000an average of $502 per time performed $65,247
an average of $160 per time performed
medical
EVALUATION AND MANAGEMENT

Subsequent hospital inpatient care, typically 25 minutes ... +

Subsequent hospital inpatient care, typically 25 minutes per day ×

Service Code: 99232
Performed in a facility
63
times performed,
2% of his services

5th 1st

most performed service for this provider most performed service in this state & specialty

15
patients got this service, 3% of his patients
4.2
average number of visits a patient made for this service
(Peers: 2.8)
$22,050an average of $350 per time performed $3,743
an average of $59 per time performed
medical
EVALUATION AND MANAGEMENT

Hospital discharge day management, 30 minutes or less

Service Code: 99238
Performed in a facility
54
times performed,
2% of his services

6th 42nd

most performed service for this provider most performed service in this state & specialty

47
patients got this service, 9% of his patients
1.1
average number of visits a patient made for this service
(Peers: 1.3)
$21,750an average of $403 per time performed $3,175
an average of $59 per time performed
medical
EVALUATION AND MANAGEMENT

Established patient office or other outpatient visit, typ... +

Established patient office or other outpatient visit, typically 15 minutes ×

Service Code: 99213
Performed in an office
35
times performed,
1% of his services

7th 5th

most performed service for this provider most performed service in this state & specialty

28
patients got this service, 5% of his patients
1.3
average number of visits a patient made for this service
(Peers: 1.7)
$7,300an average of $209 per time performed $1,847
an average of $53 per time performed
medical
EVALUATION AND MANAGEMENT

New patient office or other outpatient visit, typically 4... +

New patient office or other outpatient visit, typically 45 minutes ×

Service Code: 99204
Performed in an office
16
times performed,
0.56% of his services

8th 15th

most performed service for this provider most performed service in this state & specialty

15
patients got this service, 3% of his patients
1.1
average number of visits a patient made for this service
(Peers: 1)
$6,450an average of $403 per time performed $1,944
an average of $122 per time performed
medical
EVALUATION AND MANAGEMENT

Hospital observation or inpatient care low severity, 40 m... +

Hospital observation or inpatient care low severity, 40 minutes per day ×

Service Code: 99234
Performed in a facility
12
times performed,
0.42% of his services

9th Alert 634c0670e9b0f4e97fc9f1e1f07be123ffeab88a9de548d41da5a24a8f6054bd

most performed service for this provider 5 or fewer providers in this specialty in IL perform this service

11
patients got this service, 2% of his patients
1.1
average number of visits a patient made for this service
$2,400an average of $200 per time performed $1,312
an average of $109 per time performed

Office Visits

Medicare reimburses office visits using a five-point scale, with five being the most intensive and costly. The chart below shows what percentage of this provider’s office visits were reimbursed at each level. A higher than average proportion of costly visits is not necessarily an indication of a problem, but it may be worth asking about.

Hover over each slice to see percentage breakdown.

Manzoor Hussain Shah
Average for Pulmonary Disease Providers in Illinois

Notes: Medicare redacted this data for any services provided to fewer than 11 patients. The contact information listed above is the most current we have for this provider. The services listed on this page may have been delivered at a previous address or as part of a different practice.

Incorrect Info? If you are a provider and you believe your address is incorrect, check the listing you created on the National Provider Identifier registry. If you change your listing, send a note to checkup@propublica.org and we will update your information. If you have other questions about this data, send a note to checkup@propublica.org. Here's a link to Medicare's data on this provider.

Sources: Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, National Plan and Provider Enumeration System, American Medical Association

Services that begin with a letter come from CMS. All other codes and descriptions of the medical procedures are from the Current Procedural Terminology (CPT®) code set, copyright 2013 American Medical Association. All rights reserved. Where practical, AMA’s consumer friendly translation of the CPT descriptor was used. ProPublica has received permission from the AMA to use these codes on this site.

Read our methodology.