Dollars for Docs: Talk With Your Doctor

https://projects.propublica.org/docdollars/
You can print this page and show it to your doctor.

This database was last updated in October 2019 and should only be used as a historical snapshot. Newer data is available at the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Open Payments site.

ProPublica's Dollars for Docs database lets you search for payments to U.S.-based doctors made by pharmaceutical and medical device companies between August 2013 and December 2018. The disclosure of these payments is required under the Physician Payments Sunshine Act, a provision of the 2010 Affordable Care Act.

About This Information

  • The information that appears here comes directly from the federal government. Companies must attest to its accuracy, and doctors have the ability to contest information they believe is in error.
  • This site includes payments for such activities as speaking, consulting, meals, travel and royalties. It does not include payments for clinical research.
  • It is legal for companies to make payments to doctors as long as the payments are not a kickback or inducement to use their products.
  • Some doctors say collaborative relationships, particularly those involving research, are necessary to develop new treatments and cures. But many ethicists have raised questions about the payments, and studies show that they may influence doctors' prescribing decisions.
  • Only you can decide if this matters to you and if so, whether you want to talk with your doctor about it. If you plan to talk with your doctor (or if you already have), please help us by filling out this short survey: propub.li/participate-d4d

Preparing for Your Conversation

If you decide you'd like to talk to your doctor about this, please keep in mind:

  • Many health care professionals in our database have similar names, so you should start by asking your doctor if the person mentioned in this payment record is really him/her.
  • Your doctor may not know he or she is listed as receiving payments, especially if the payments are small. You can direct your doctor to this site (the URL will be printed at the top of the payment record) or directly to the government's site here: https://openpaymentsdata.cms.gov/physician/45675
  • Some doctors are happy to discuss this information with you. Others might not be. The best approach is to ask questions and to not be accusatory.

Questions You Might Want to Ask

  • Is this you?
  • What type of work do you do with these companies?
  • Have you prescribed me any drugs that are manufactured by companies you've taken payments from?
  • Are there non-drug alternatives that I may want to consider first?
  • Are there less expensive generic alternatives to the drugs you have prescribed?
  • What devices have you used in my care that are manufactured by companies you've taken payments from?

Dollars for Docs: Talk With Your Doctor

https://projects.propublica.org/docdollars/doctors/pid/45675
If you spot an error, please let us know at [email protected].

This database was last updated in October 2019 and should only be used as a historical snapshot. Newer data is available at the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Open Payments site.

PERMINDER BHATIA

Listed Specialty: Neurology
736 E BULLARD AVE, #101, FRESNO, CA, 93710

2018 Payments: At a Glance

199

payments

$8,780

payment total

40

companies paid this doctor

Types of Payments

Category Payments Payment Value
Food and Beverage
 189 $3,363
Promotional Speaking/Other
 1 $2,505
Travel and Lodging
 7 $1,736
Consulting
 1 $1,125
Education
 1 $52

Drugs & Devices in 2018

Totals listed below account for all payments from that mention this product. Beginning in 2016, the government began classifying products as drugs, devices, biologics or medical supplies. Below, you will see drugs (drugs and biologics) and devices (devices and medical supplies). If a payment record mentions more than one product, the entire value will be included in each of those products. When no products are listed, they are not included in the list below.

Product Name Product Type Payments†
ACTHAR

drug

 $2,730
GENERAL DBS

device

 $1,209
Payments with no listed product

N/A

 $1,141
VNS THERAPY

device

 $885
TECFIDERA

drug

 $280
AJOVY

drug

 $178
SOLIRIS

drug

 $172
AIMOVIG

drug

 $157
TYSABRI

drug

 $155
BUNAVAIL

drug

 $140
INGREZZA

drug

 $133
BRIVIACT

drug

 $132
NORTHERA

drug

 $127
NUPLAZID

drug

 $125
APTIOM

drug

 $107
ZOHYDRO ER

drug

 $90
TROKENDI XR

drug

 $79
EMGALITY

drug

 $64
TRINTELLIX

drug

 $63
GOCOVRI

drug

 $62
† May not add up to dollar total at top of page, since a payment record may not be associated with any product or can be associated with several products.

For ease of printing, only the 20 drugs and devices with the highest payments are displayed. For a complete list, please visit: https://projects.propublica.org/docdollars/doctors/pid/45675

Payment Details

When How Much Related To What For From Third Party Payee
Mar 19, 2018 $2,505 ACTHAR Promotional Speaking/Other MALLINCKRODT LLC
Sep 21, 2018 $1,125 No Listed Product Consulting VERTICAL PHARMACEUTICALS, LLC
Mar 9, 2018 $465 VNS THERAPY Travel and Lodging LIVANOVA USA, INC.
Sep 28, 2018 $461 GENERAL DBS Travel and Lodging BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORPORATION
Sep 28, 2018 $288 GENERAL DBS Travel and Lodging BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORPORATION
Sep 29, 2018 $179 GENERAL DBS Food and Beverage BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORPORATION
Mar 10, 2018 $175 VNS THERAPY Travel and Lodging LIVANOVA USA, INC.
Sep 28, 2018 $140 GENERAL DBS Travel and Lodging BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORPORATION
Sep 29, 2018 $140 GENERAL DBS Travel and Lodging BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORPORATION
Sep 20, 2018 $125 NUPLAZID Food and Beverage ACADIA PHARMACEUTICALS INC
Oct 30, 2018 $122 AJOVY Food and Beverage TEVA PHARMACEUTICALS USA, INC.
Mar 16, 2018 $113 ACTHAR Food and Beverage MALLINCKRODT LLC
Feb 15, 2018 $105 NORTHERA Food and Beverage LUNDBECK LLC
Mar 9, 2018 $103 VNS THERAPY Food and Beverage LIVANOVA USA, INC.
Mar 10, 2018 $98 VNS THERAPY Food and Beverage LIVANOVA USA, INC.
Jul 31, 2018 $88 AIMOVIG Food and Beverage AMGEN INC.
Mar 21, 2018 $65 ACTHAR Travel and Lodging MALLINCKRODT LLC
Sep 10, 2018 $65 BUNAVAIL Food and Beverage BIODELIVERY SCIENCES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
Mar 9, 2018 $52 TYSABRI Education BIOGEN, INC.
Nov 15, 2018 $36 VIMPAT Food and Beverage UCB, INC.

For ease of printing, 20 payments are displayed, the largest appearing on top. For a full list of payments, please visit: https://projects.propublica.org/docdollars/doctors/pid/45675

Note: We have made some effort to normalize the data and eliminate duplicates, but the data is primarily as it has been reported by the companies to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. To purchase the normalized data, please visit the ProPublica Data Store. If you spot an error, please let us know at [email protected].

This site includes data published by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services on June 28, 2019.